We are providing Projects for your business growth and to meet new challenges. Here are some projects prepared by our team of "Developing New Projects"
for the Guarantee of your business growth
Summary
In this report we tried to explore the how the advertisement is creating its
impacts on the society. In the sake of completion of our case studies we have
visited the many advertisement agencies. Like paragon advertising agency,
Interflow communications, orient maccan. MCM advertisers, GH Thaver. Synergy
Group. By visiting theses companies we find the results that how the
advertisement is shaping up the society or just mirror the values of the
society. The topic is related with the following topic
Stereotyping that how the stereotyping is helping the society to enhance its
values or just mirror up. In our society the major character of that creating
the impact being impacted by the others are women, men children’s and the young
ones. In our report we discuss this character briefly. That how women are ported
in the advertisements and how these ads are crating their impacts on our
society. Similarly we also discuss that how the ads creating their negative and
the positive impact on society. Me and my group member visited the organization
and found that how in the Pakistani society these characters are being
performing their roles to build up the society.
Our main question about the advertising to the advertising agencies is following
because our total research is dependent on the few questions that we ask from
the head or the representative of the organization
What are the social responsibilities of the advertiser?
How the advertising shapes society values simply mirrors them?
Stereotyping and impacts to influence people?
Is the stereotyping creating the clutter?
What are the harms of the society towards the economic? Political, cultural,
moral and religious harms of advertising?
Is the advertising the mirror which society emulates?
What is the role of women, men, young ones and how they portrayed?
In respects of these questions and few more questions we prepare our report from
the material and the data they provide us and few from advertising websites and
some from education sites.
Advertising and Society
Life without advertising would be dull
with out the advertisement the life color will dull and unisexual because if u
don’t see a charming face on the try or any their media u will not able to
please itself and can not enjoy the beauty of life.
Advertisement is every things it effect each and ever aspects of life from child
to young ones and to young ones to old one .how can the life can be colorful
with out advertisement
Consumers feel that advertising is everywhere and that this ubiquity has evolved
over time. As such advertising is as much part of the environment as the traffic
and the trees. For some, mainly the older respondents, there is perhaps too much
advertising, too much pressure to buy but the majority embrace it as part of
life. When asked to think about life without advertising the response was that
life would be very, very dull. There would be a lack of essential and desirable
information. There would be less entertainment. There would be less street
colour.
Advertising Role in Shaping or Mirroring Society
Does advertising reveal our society as it is, as it wants it to be, or does life
mirror he images brought to life by advertising? The answer to this question is
controversial, but, I believe that advertising and society observe and
simultaneously reflect each other depending upon who is looking into the mirror.
“We see life not as it is, but as we are.”
Advertising mirrors values
Advertising professionals tend to believe that the best they can do is spot
trends and develop advertising messages that connect with them. Advertisers
believe advertising mirrors values rather than sets them.
Competition in the Marketplace
Advertising serves to drive competition in the marketplace by stimulating
consumer spending and ultimately increasing the amount of money that businesses
make. Advertising does not necessitate that business improve its products or
service due to competition, but I do believe that competition requires that the
advertising produced must match the product benefit
Dynamic Marketplace
Advertising stabilizes an otherwise dynamic marketplace. As consumers remain
cognizant of products through various types of advertising, companies are not as
susceptible to changes or shifts in the ebb and flow of business. Each business
is also forced to maintain its prices within a reasonable range compared to its
competitors. Consumers are not unwilling participants in this system, they
consciously and freely participate, and are fully aware, and can also
distinguish between facts and false claims from the marketplace.
Creates a Want
Advertising creates a want where there was no need. It stimulates purchase and
consumption. However, in contradiction to strong effects theorists, I believe
that this stimulation is more fleeting and imaginative than harmful.
Images & Perceptions
It creates product images and perceptions for the consumer. Depending upon the
advertising message and the type of product advertised, consumers hope to
satisfy their needs for self-actualization and self-esteem, their need to
belong, and other symbolic meanings gained through the experience of consumer
consumption. Advertising’s role is to connect meanings form product to consumer.
More on that later... First, how does it work?
If we believe that each individual is a product of his own set of experiences,
learned knowledge, and beliefs and expectations about the world, each
individual’s understanding of advertising is affected by these same
characteristics. Each of us has a mental filter through which each ad permeates.
Some of our filters are tightly knit, letting only certain things pass, while
others have wide spaces that let everything through. Even then, each individual
decides what she will do with the information that gets past the filter.
Culture through mass media & Advertising
As advertisement has come to absorb many socializing functions of the family,
they have offered us images of the family which would act as touchstones by
which we gauge our own daily experiences. Seductively realistic portrayals of
family life in the ads, especially on TV screen watched in one’s own living room
at home, may be the basis for “our most common and pervasive conceptions and
beliefs about what is natural and what is right.”
Nothing is more politically and culturally influential than the advertisement
that is capable of making people accept what is” natural” and what is
“right,” without ever being noticed of the fact of being influenced. In the TV
advertisements, children are depicted as happy smiling consumers of such
“children’s stuffs” as snacks, drinks, and other commodities of comfort and
indulgence.
The family happiness is presented as the way of consumption. Children are the
ultimate consumers for whom the family, which is now reconstructed as the unit
of commodity consumers, buys the “children’s” commodities in order for children
and family to become “happy.” In the advertisements of the children’s TV
programs, parents are typically the providers of goods and services of which
Because of the impact advertising has on media that depend on it for revenue,
advertisers have an opportunity to exert a positive influence on decisions about
media content.
This they do by supporting material of excellent intellectual, aesthetic and
moral quality presented with the public interest in view, and particularly by
encouraging and making possible media presentations which are oriented to
minorities whose needs might otherwise go unnerved.
Moreover, advertising can itself contribute to the betterment of society by
uplifting and inspiring people and motivating them to act in ways that benefit
themselves and others. Advertising can brighten lives simply by being witty,
tasteful and entertaining. Some advertisements are instances of popular art,
with a vivacity and elan all their own.
News Distribution System
They have performed extremely well in the joint initiative with newspapers,
covering threats to the news distribution system,"
Economic Changes of Advertising in a Society
Advertising can play an important role in the process by which an economic
system guided by moral norms and responsive to the common good contributes to
human development. It is a necessary part of the functioning of modern market
economies, which today either exist or are emerging in many parts of the world
and which — provided they conform to moral standards based upon integral human
development and the common good — currently seem to be "the most efficient
instrument for utilizing resources and effectively responding to needs" of a
socio-economic kind.
In such a system, advertising can be a useful tool for sustaining honest and
ethically responsible competition that contributes to economic growth in the
service of authentic human development. "The Church looks with favor on the
growth of man's productive capacity, and also on the ever widening network of
relationships and exchanges between persons and social groups....From this point
of view she encourages advertising, which can become a wholesome and efficacious
instrument for reciprocal help among men.
Advertising does this, among other ways, by informing people about the
availability of rationally desirable new products and services and improvements
in existing ones, helping them to make informed, prudent consumer decisions,
contributing to efficiency and the lowering of prices, and stimulating economic
progress through the expansion of business and trade. All of this can contribute
to the creation of new jobs, higher incomes and a more decent and humane way of
life for all. It also helps pay for publications, programming and productions —
including those of the Church — that bring information, entertainment and
inspiration to people around the world.
Advertising plays an economic role in the way it creates demand, which
means people want or feel a need to buy and use a product. Demand creation,
which means an external message, drives people to feel this need or want, is an
economic force that drives progress and the search for better products.
Advertising plays an important role in creating and sustaining that force.
Demand creation becomes a question of ethics when social critics charge that
the demand is artificial and the products really aren’t needed but that people’s
wants are being manipulated unnecessarily.
Advertising is also a factor in the increased cost of branded products.
However, advertising also supports brands we like and teaches us how to use new
products that make our lives easier and our health better. Advertising is used
in social marketing to support good causes.
Shaping up society through Political Advertisement
The Church values the democratic system inasmuch as it ensures the participation
of citizens in making political choices, guarantees to the governed the
possibility both of electing and holding accountable those who govern them, and
of replacing them through peaceful means when appropriate.
Political advertising can make a contribution to democracy analogous to its
contribution to economic well being in a market system guided by moral norms. As
free and responsible media in a democratic system help to counteract tendencies
toward the monopolization of power on the part of oligarchies and special
interests, so political advertising can make its contribution by informing
people about the ideas and policy proposals of parties and candidates, including
new candidates not previously known to the public.
Advertisement and Education
It is hardly surprising that men have a greater propensity towards violence when
they are bombarded with it on a daily basis. Television, movies and advertising
continue to glorify the role of the "macho" man through action movies and
television, violent video games and toys, pornography and much more. Media
education and advocacy campaigns have two central objectives; to elicit change
in the existing media, and to use media to transmit alternative messages.
Changing existing media - This is accomplished mainly through lobbying
governments, standards councils, television networks, manufacturers etc. to make
their products less violent, or to develop and enforce quality control
legislation.
The Media Awareness Network in Pakistan, for example, monitors compliance with
Canadian broadcasting standards on violence in programming, lobbies the
government to develop tougher standards, and conducts public education campaigns
about particularly violent programming. Transmitting alternative messages - A
number of non-governmental organizations have begun to use media to broadcast
messages of non-violence and respect. Other men's groups in Nicaragua have been
working with men in urban and rural communities to explore their own roles in
their relationships.
Advertisements as Mirrors of Prevailing Norms
Marketers claim that advertising simply mirrors the attitudes and values of the
surrounding culture. No doubt advertising, like the media of social
communications in general, does act as a mirror. But, also like media in
general, it is a mirror that helps shape the reality it reflects, and sometimes
it presents a distorted image of reality.
Advertisers are selective about the values and attitudes to be fostered and
encouraged, promoting some while ignoring others. This selectivity does not
impart credence to the notion that advertising does no more than reflect the
surrounding culture. For example, the absence from advertising of certain racial
and ethnic groups in some multi-racial or multi-ethnic societies can help to
create problems of image and identity, especially among those neglected, and the
almost inevitable impression in commercial advertising that an abundance of
possessions leads to happiness and fulfillment can be both misleading and
frustrating.
Advertising also has an indirect but powerful impact on society through its
influence on media. Many publications and broadcasting operations depend on
advertising revenue for survival. This often is true of religious media as well
as commercial media. For their part, advertisers naturally seek to reach
audiences; and the media, striving to deliver audiences to advertisers, must
shape their content so to attract audiences of the size and demographic
composition sought. This economic dependency of media and the power it confers
upon advertisers carries with it serious responsibilities for both.
Advertising has three key roles
The positive attitude towards advertising comes from its multiplicity of roles.
It is, of course, a source of information particularly useful for new products
or services and for prices and promotions. It is a significant source of
entertainment. It is also a part of everyday culture. Advertising is talked
about in day-to-day conversations.
Words and phrases become part of colloquial language. Not knowing about aspects
of advertising would for many, particularly the younger respondents, mean
missing out. Information, entertainment and part of everyday culture are the
three levels on which advertising works and the most effective advertising
operates on all three. Pure informational advertising may engage the target for
whom it is relevant but it will do little more than that.
Advertising that entertains can engage a much broader target of consumers and
build equity for the future. Advertising that becomes part of everyday culture
has its life extended beyond the time of the campaign because it is used and
reinforced by the consumers themselves. Advertising that achieves all three
roles has maximum power.
Advertising is an indicator of Business Health
Advertising is inevitably perceived as a selling tool but it is also for
consumers a barometer of the economy. For those not involved in business, the
advertising is the key indicator of a company or brand’s health. As you begin
marketing and promoting your online business you are going to run into some
unbelievable advertising opportunities. Generally speaking if the ad offering
sounds too good to be true--It is. There are companies that will tell you they
will get you listed in the top 10 search engines or place your link on millions
of sites or they will get you listed in the top 10 returns of search engines.
This last one sounds similar to the first, but there is a big difference.
The companies that tell you they will get you listed in the top 10 of the major
search engines would have to defy all the principles of math to do this. They
could not work with more than a few companies in order to achieve this and
honestly, there is no way they can get you listed in the top 10 of the search
engines placements at all unless they make up their own search terms and people
search on that specific term.
Stay away from the companies that tell you they are going to place you in search
engines for a fee, for the most part they will do nothing more than use a site
software submitter. You can get your own software for this or use an online
service and submit your site yourself for a lot less than what most SEO
companies charge for this service. Guaranteed traffic-- They work fine for free
sites or if your goal is to build a database of names, but if you are selling a
product or service, you will get hits, but not many sales.
Mass email -- Any company that tells you they will send your ad to millions of
people for $20 or $30 is simply taking your money. This might sound inviting,
but do not waste your money. They are either using site submit tools or sending
your ad to millions of harvested email addresses. The companies who tell you
they are going to submit your site to millions of pages will most likely do what
they say, but you will not see any return and may even get you Spam complaints.
Mass emails are a complete waste of your money regardless of what product you
are selling. There are many sites that will tell you they will send your ad to
double opt-in lists of people. We have tried over a dozen of these services and
have barely received a hit, much less sales. The problem is you lose control
over your ad when you use mass email companies. There is no way to verify the ad
was sent and if you could verify it was sent, there is no way to tell it was
sent to the numbers they promise. Plus, you run the risk of being accused of
Spam Solo ads-- These are by far one of the best methods of promoting your
product and service.
They are targeted, you can verify the numbers and you can subscribe using a
unique email and verify the ad was sent on the day and time it was up posed to
be sent. Consultants-- Use your best judgment when hiring consultants, call some
or send an email and ask about a money back guarantee if they cannot meet the
objectives they set forth. I am not a big believer in money-back guarantees
because if a service is valuable and you can see the value before you buy, then
a money back guarantee is not necessary. However, if someone comes to you and
says, I can make your site profitable within 30 or 60 or 90 days and it is going
to cost you X amount of money, then they should give you your money back if they
do not achieve the desired results.
A good consultant will work with companies that he or she knows they can help by
relying on their background and expertise in certain areas of marketing and
advertising. Nobody knows everything, but if someone has an expertise in an area
that I lack knowledge with, I would hire him or her in a second if they can
honestly help me and they can prove they can help me and they will back up what
they tell me. We get emails every day from people who want to join ISOR with the
plan of retiring in a month, making a million dollars without doing anything,
etc. and we turn every one of them down.
There is no business on the Internet or in traditional business where you can
accomplish this type of unrealistic goal. There are, however consultants who
will tell you what you want to hear, just to get your business. They take your
money and run and they will not help you a bit. We hired a copy writer one time
that seemed like a good fit for our company and only after she finished the
writing at $120 an hour did she tell me that she would not buy my product. Not
because she could not benefit from it, but she refused to pay for anything
online. Her copy was terrible and we ended up re--writing the entire sales page.
Her feelings and beliefs came across in her writings. It was simply impossible
for her to write positively when her mind was telling her negative things.
We have many marketing and advertising partners and all the companies we partner
with have been tested by us to offer valuable services, but there are thousands
of other companies on the Internet and you might find a very good company with a
very good service that works for you and within your budget. Not all companies
are out to cheat you, but the purpose of this article is to forewarn you
regarding where you spend your advertising dollars. We have spent a lot of money
and time buying and trying different advertising options and by using our own ad
campaign and link tracking system for all our advertising campaigns we have the
data to back up what we say.
Research your advertising options carefully and do not get pulled into a good
deal just because it sounds like a good deal. You do not need to spend a lot of
money to advertise and promote your business, you just need to use your common
sense and think long term.
Advertising Size Matters
It became apparent that the perceived scale of any advertising is important to
the way consumers receive it. If advertising is thought to have a lot of money
behind it or to have significant presence then this adds credence to the message
and adds stature to the brand. So large spaces, mainstream media, sustains
presence, the use of colour, a clever or ‘big idea’ all add weight to the
advertising and positive perceptions of the brand.
Advertising Quality Matters
The effect of advertising can be enhanced by how consumers perceive the quality
of the advertising idea (how clever it is), the quality of the production, the
quality of the media and the quality of its mood, tone and style. All reflect on
how consumers perceive the quality and credibility of the brand.
The Brand Matters
If the brand is perceived well or the brand is trusted because it is known and
established then there is a virtuous circle and the advertising message will be
even more credible. If a brand has a recognized area of expertise then consumers
question less the claims of new products within that area.
Advertising has got better
The public is more critical of advertising than it has ever been. This is
because of a belief that advertising is better than it ever was. It is felt to
be cleverer, more reflective of real life, more entertaining and more tuned to
different targets. ‘Clever’ advertising is good advertising throughout
the research, regardless of consumer life-stage or sex, clever was the word used
to describe advertising that engaged and entertained. Clever could be clever in
humour, originality of the idea, play on words or special effects.
Not all is positive
On the negative side consumers perceive one major trend. It is a trend that
threatens to seriously undermine advertising in general. This is the development
of what we have termed ‘Untruthful truthful advertising’. This is the category
of advertising that does not literally lie. It is assumed to be ‘legally ‘true
but it is economical with the truth. It does not communicate the true or whole
picture.
It is advertising of serious products, mainly financial, that highlights
substantial benefits but is vague in its communication of the implications or
downsides. It is epitomized by the perceived growing presence of advertising for
accident claims companies, consolidation of debts and loan offers. The threat to
advertising in general is that as the cancer of ‘Untruthful truthful’
advertising spreads consumers become more cynical, critical and doubtful about
other advertising claims. ‘They are all the same’.
Acceptable & unacceptable advertising Hyperbole
This does not mean that advertisers cannot use hyperbole. There has always been
hyperbole in advertising and much of it is acceptable because it is companies
being seen to be ‘putting their best foot forward’, advertising their wares.
More important this acceptable hyperbole is associated with small ticket items
such as food and household products and if the reality does not quite live up to
expectations it does not really matter.
The new unacceptable hyperbole is in areas where decisions taken can seriously
affect an individual’s life and happiness, like finance. Advertisers are thought
to be hiding behind the small print and weasels. This small print is, in the
consumer’s mind, definitely there to protect the advertiser not the consumer.
Recognized weasels are words such as ‘from’, ‘terms and conditions apply’,
limited stocks available’ ‘subject to status’.
The role of the Regulators
Overall the regulators were thought by the public to be ‘doing a good job’.
However, the area of ‘untruthful truthful’ advertising was singled out in all
groups as the one area where ‘they’ should be more active, more invasive, more
controlling in order to protect consumers.
The only other area of any notable concern was posters (more often referred to
as billboards). Unlike the watershed on television and the implicit targeting of
press, radio and cinema, poster advertising is exposed to all ages and cultural
group. As a result there are more onuses on this medium not to offend or upset.
Entertainment is key
Essentially consumers have higher and higher expectations of advertising. With
the proliferation of media and the developments in technology there will be
increasing opportunities for them to edit out advertising and notice only those
pieces of communication that interest or entertain them.
They believe advertising will have to continue to get better to get their
attention. Continuing to get better is about more of advertising being clever or
cleverer. Cleverer in its originality and in its ability to engage and
entertain. The rewards from advertising will come from advertising that in its
turn rewards the consumer.
Stereotypes
Because most television programs are quite short, the identities of characters
must be established as quickly as possible. To do this, television writers often
use stereotypes. A stereotype is a fixed or conventional image of a person or
group of people. Stereotypes generally conform to a pattern of dress and
behavior that is easily recognized and understood. Often, a judgment is made
about the person or group being stereotyped. That judgment may be +ive or -ive.
Generally, stereotypes are less real, more perfect, (or imperfect) and more
predictable than their real-life counterparts. A typical male stereotype, for
example, is of a "real man" who is adventurous, masterful, intelligent, and
unshakable. Such sex-role stereotypes are intended to present viewers with a
character they can easily recognize and relate to. Their danger, however, is
that, if seen often, they can affect the way a viewer perceives men in general.
Male stereotyping can narrow one's notion of what men can be and do; it can
affect women's and children's expectations of men; it can even shape men's and
boys' own views of themselves and of how they should behave.
While commercial television has improved in its portrayal of females, many of
the women featured on TV continue to be depicted as someone's wife or
girlfriend. Television children are generally cast in gender-related roles - the
girls playing with dolls while the boys play at sports - and all are "cutesy"
and talk as though they were insightful adults. Similarly, the characterization
of mothers-in-law, the elderly, gays, police officers, and truck drivers tends
toward the stereotypical.
Culture and class stereotypes are also prevalent in television. Traditionally,
blacks were portrayed as either happy-go-lucky servants or dangerous criminals,
and while these stereotypes linger, we are now seeing what might be described as
upright, intelligent, middle-class black characters. Similarly, Pakistani
peoples are now being portrayed as something other than buckskin-wearing teepee
dwellers. Too often, however, minorities are portrayed stereotypically and
almost never as powerful or rich as the white majority.
Because stereotyping can lead children to form false impressions of various
societal groups, it is important that students recognize stereotypes and
understand the role they play in television's portrayal of life. To become
television-wise, then, students must tune in to the ways television treats
people, recognize how they themselves relate to TV characters.
Stereotypes in Advertising
_________
– A perceiver’s knowledge, beliefs, and expectancies about some human
_________that
are contained within a cognitive structure.
e.g., truck driver
_________
Stereotypes – Beliefs shared by the culture (society) concerning the attributes
of a group.
_________
Stereotypes – Individually held beliefs about the attributes of a group.
-
Based on _________ experience with the
group
-
Based on _________ standards --
Egalitarian Beliefs
Stereotypes are good and bad.
-
Good = 1.) Can ease _________.
2.) Allow for smooth and
positive _________.
-
Bad = 1.) Stereotypes may be
partial, incomplete,
_________. 2.) Particularly
bad when applied to all members
of a group _________.
_________
Stereotypes are bad:
-
Can lead to unrealistic
_________
-
Can lead to _________
judgment standards (e.g., Ho and
Driscoll)
Examples of stereotype _________:
-
_________
Stereotypes
-
_________
Stereotypes
-
_________
Stereotypes
-
_________
Stereotypes
-
_________
Stereotypes
Etc.
Stereotypes vs. Prejudice vs. Discrimination
Recall the _________ Model of attitudes?
Corresponds to:
Affect: _________ _________
Behavior: _________ _________
Cognition: _________ _________
Why the distinction?
Because of Attitudinal _________.
e.g. Asians, Businesswomen
Are stereotypes pervasive in advertising?
_________
Recent Study – Coltrane & Messineo (2000)
Analyzed _________ads
Findings;
_________
Differences –
-
Women more likely to be shown as _________
-
Women more likely to be shown in a _________
-
Women more likely to be _________and
portrayed as followers
-
Women were _________ more likely to be
shown as _________
-
Women were _________ more likely to be
shown as sex objects than _________
Ethnic Differences –
-
_________
most likely to be shown in job settings
-
If a job setting, Whites _________ more
likely to be in a _________ role than
African Americans
-
No instances of Asians of _________
serving as a _________
-
African American men _________ more
likely to be shown as _________ vs. White
men
Conclusion – "Sexist and racist stereotypes are pervasive and cut across all
audiences..."
e.g.,
Cognitive Structure
Asian Stereotypes
Advertisements (the media as a whole) have the potential to influence
stereotypic beliefs… both strengthening and weakening associative links between
nodes.
Stereotypes influence both how:
1.) People view the group.
2.) How the group views themselves.
Great impact on
how groups "are."
STEREOTYPING IN ADVERTISEMENTS
Stereotyping in advertisements is not a strange phenomenon anymore. The
stereotyping is related with its content which ranges from gender portrayal,
social class portrayal, to ethnic portrayal. S. Rogers said, as quoted in The
Portrayal of Women in Outdoor Advertising, that women are always represented by
a stereotype which ignores the fact that Australians are not all white,
able-bodied, heterosexual, thin, affluent and under thirty five. The
stereotyping is also can be seen from how they are advertised – where they are
appeared and when they are shown on televisions. When the advertisements are
shown near business center, the advertisement might be purpose for businessmen
and while the advertisements are placed near housing complex, the advertiser
might have the belief that the viewers would be like housewives, families, and
children.
Television, Gender Stereotypes & Young Viewers
(I) Debate in Perspective
Much attention today is given to the so called 'effects' of television,
particularly the 'extremes' of violence portrayed. Recent concern has focused
upon certain somewhat disturbing films and the influences they may have had in
encouraging human acts of violence and cruelty.
However, due to such specific
attentions, the possible influence of the 'everyday' television which we take
for granted as part of our western cultural tradition is often overlooked, or
perhaps underestimated. Faced with a polarization of views from the public and
politicians alike the importance of it as a research area is often undermined as
more radical, if you like 'short, sharp, shock', responses come to the fore.
However, almost every home has a television and children spend on average more
time in front of it than they do attending school; as an 'informal curriculum'
it would thus seem unwise not to pay some research attention to it, after all
much time, money and effort is paid to our formal education system and it is
arguable that television is even more important in the lives of our children.
It is thus to such an area that this dissertation turns. Possible influences of
television representation on children are often difficult to carry out.
Researchers attempting to gain information from within the school or classroom
environment all too often quickly become regarded in the assumed position of
'teacher', and as such many children can be either too guarded, or too intent on
pleasing, in their responses.
Attempts to avoid such situations of traditional formality have thus often been
focused upon the family environment itself. Here again, any intrusion into the
everyday world of a typical family can meet with much the same types of problems
as the school route may give rise to. Similarly the parental head of the family
may offer research information which is not specifically that which has been
directly derived from the child itself, and the 'pecking order' of the family
may give opportunities for one or more members to dominate responses and
interpretations.
As such we have attempted to bear such influences in mind whilst bringing this
work together. As the subject's father my position of insight should hopefully
be a good one, especially if we make every effort not to let my parental bias
rule my more objective observations. 'Inside information', if treated correctly
and with due caution, can be of great help; often children may not say exactly
what they mean and personality traits such as an ironic sense of humor might 'colour'
responses greatly.
Such individual idiosyncrasies might only be apparent to someone who knows the
child well and it is such an informed position that I hope to be able to occupy.
Thus both Jack's social setting, his viewing environment, and my own methodology
must be explained in order to put this work into context.
(ii) Methodology
Whilst researching into potential influences towards the creation of a child's
gender identity it is important to bear in mind the many diverse and complex
factors working towards its formation. However it is difficult to imagine that
either will work independently of each other; they will interact on many
different levels. Faced with such an array of difficulties it is wise to
investigate one small area at a time, employing a narrow focus rather than one
which is too large and perhaps unmanageable. I have been conscious to avoid
influencing Jack's views too heavily and as such have tried to employ a
qualitative research methodology which is derived as much from Jack himself as
is possible, obviously bearing in mind the content of the programmed involved,
which cannot be ignored.
Towards this We have relied upon what was the most salient of discussion points
instigated by Jack whilst watching the first episode of the new series. As
supporting evidence again I felt it important to rely on material which was as
far from my personal influence as was possible; thus questionnaires, stories and
drawings, all completed at his own pace, have been analyzed, and an attempt has
been made to set them into a wider context via my own interpretation.
From such a methodological base it is hoped that some sort of conclusion as to
Jack's process of mediation between television representation and 'real world'
experiences might be reached. It must be stressed that due to the nature of the
work, this conclusion will undoubtedly be narrow in scope, but hopefully
nonetheless valuable as an insight into one small part of Jack's engagement with
matters of gender.
(I) Categorization and Contemporary Relevance
Children ... go from the general to the particular, from genre to series to
program following major transformational routes.
Formation of 'understanding the myth' as a key early development in children’s
decoding of television. Each new viewing experience, however trivial, may be
added to existing structures of knowledge, continually building towards a
greater understanding of television, based upon an increased cognitive awareness
of both anticipation and expectation.
New Adventures of Superman
was to enjoy a category all of its own. He felt it could perhaps be included in
certain categories but could not sit easily alongside others in the same area.
Yes it could be for 'kids', but was not primarily for them. Yes it was 'funny'
but not as 'Mr. Bean' is funny and yes it was sometimes in 'space', but not all
the time. Thus it was to be categorized on its own and Jack struggled to offer
an explanation as to what type of programme it actually was; it seemed to be 'a
bit of everything really'.
It appeared that through his struggles to Accommodate The New Adventures of
Superman into an understandable category, Jack was indeed creating a new
genre to add to his existing knowledge of television structures, that of
'drama'. Older more experienced viewers may have easily set the programme
immediately in the children’s genre. However, to the ever developing mind of the
child such a programme may indeed be used to push knowledge and experience a
little further, perhaps into relatively new and challenging territories.
New Adventures of Superman
may well be grounded upon the excitement and daring of the traditional
'super-hero', of which Jack is well aware and can experience in many programmes
within the children’s television genre. However, New Adventures of Superman
also brings factors which may not be readily found in previously encoded areas,
those of romance, respect and morality amongst others. I would surmise that it
is to such areas that Jack is drawn and it is upon such reasons that difficulty
was encountered in trying to label the programme.
Programmes which have been, 'seen, understood and stored' can be categorized
quickly and with little problem. Programmes that are too advanced and therefore
ones which the child is unable to apply a full understanding may also be
'dismissed' quickly and with little difficulty. However, when a child has become
involved with a programme which can challenge previous knowledge and help build
upon existing structures of understanding, then a categorization problem may
occur. it would therefore seem, that for Jack at least, New Adventures of
Superman serves such a role.
As such the creation and understanding of genre whether it regards books or
television programmes, is an important one in the creation of better structures
of knowledge regarding different media. Above all Jack can, and does, use his
own mind to choose, and whether or not these choices reflect escapism,
triviality or past, present or forward thinking, they are his own. The formation
of such criteria as genre and his ability to confidently and coherently sort
through a vast array of differing programmes shows that he does have an overall,
objective view of them. He is also open-minded enough to employ some programmes
in his search to further expand his developing mind and, in turn, further his
understanding of something which he knows he is able to reject, modify, accept
or simply use as a means to an end - television.
Gender Representation
(I) Developmental Importance
In the longer term television has the potential to shape children’s sex-role
attitudes... more women should be presented on television.
It is true that for most children in our
society, television offers many more opportunities to view differences in
sex-role relationships, than does their immediate, everyday world of reference.
As such its potential influence upon their outlook should not be overlooked or
dismissed. Indeed for many, if not most, children gender identification is
perhaps the most fundamental and salient of all the frames of self reference
available.
Above all it is understood that it will remain as a constant, despite changes in
other developmental areas; from childhood to adulthood gender will remain, and
as such is understandably regarded as a key element of the 'self' and utilized
as a primary building block towards the development of a sense of 'place' in the
world. Given that gender identification is employed from an early age, as a
basic strategy in the child’s negotiation of a vast array of complex social
relationships, and that "the cultures of childhood... are enmeshed in the larger
divisions of the social world". It seems somewhat unrealistic to expect the
child to question stereotypical representation.
Indeed as an area of such stability, it may well be argued that children
actually like and enjoy 'being gendered', continually seeking reinforcements
which the media would perhaps be foolish to ignore. Throughout the world
children actively seek reinforcements as "futures where the power of adulthood
will be available". 'Boys do choose blue and girls do choose pink', actively
making selections for their own uses and purposes, be they socialization,
information, escapism or identification; as active interpreters, if not
endorsers, of their own environment then should their judgments be questioned?
Bad Stereotyping
For lack of a better word, let’s call this “conversational discrimination.” I
don’t assume that every stranger I meet wants to talk about college football.
But I drew an inference about my conversational partner, based on his membership
in the “white-male-businessmen of Texas and Oklahoma group” and used that
inference to direct my behavior. As Judge Posner reminded us, in his review of
Blink, in situations where one doesn’t know a lot about an individual, it may
“sensible to ascribe the group's average characteristics to each member of the
group, even though one knows that many members deviate from the average.” As it
turns out, my assumption was largely correct. I had lot of really great
conversations about college football. (Let's be clear this was not a hardship:
I'm happy to talk about college football until the cows come home).
The reason this stereotype was so useful was that I used as much of the
available information about my conversational partner as I could. The fact that
I was in Texas and Oklahoma mattered a lot. I wouldn’t have assumed that I could
talk about college football with a similar group of white male business types
from, say, Silicon Valley. The fact that they were businessmen mattered, and
not, says, graphic designers or actors.
The fact that they were men and not women mattered, and I know from experience
that if I’m choosing a sports topic for conversation with an black male
businessman, I’ll probably guess basketball—particularly if the person I’m
talking to is from the East Coast. The point is the accuracy of stereotypes is a
reflection—in large part—of their specificity: the more information you can use
to build a generalization, the better off you are.
This is my third (and last) comment on the Ayres study. My first point, as those
of you who have been following my thoughts on this know, is that price
discrimination against black males by car salesmen is morally wrong. My second
point is that it is a bad business strategy. My third—and in some ways most
important point—is that its lousy stereotyping.
Let’s go back to the study. The male and female, black and white testers who
Ayres sent out to car dealerships all gave the salesmen the same set of facts.
They were all roughly the same age (late twenties). They all drove the same kind
of car into the lot. They all dressed neatly and conservatively. They identified
themselves as college-educated professionals (sample job: systems analyst at a
bank). And they said they lived in the upper-income Chicago neighborhood of
Steeleville.
The car salesman, then, has several pieces of data from which to create his
stereotype. He has the gender, race, age, occupation, educational level, and
class (or at least a class proxy) of his potential customer. And what did he do?
With the black men, he zeroed in on age and race, and ignored everything else.
In his critique of my analysis of Ayres, Judge Posner did the same thing. When
he says that it may be “sensible to ascribe the group's average characteristics
to each member of the group,” the “group” he’s talking about is race. But why is
Posner—like the car salesmen—so hung up about race? Wouldn’t it be just as
sensible, in the case of black men, to define their “group” as the group of
college-educated, upper income professionals? So too with Steve Sailer. He says
that car salesman are acting rationally, based on the fact that black men—as a
group—like to be seen overpaying for cars. I have made my feelings known about
what I see as the motivation behind that particular comment. But let’s just
focus here on its appropriateness. Why is Sailer—like Posner and Ayres’ car
dealers—so intent on zeroing in on what is only one of many available and
relevant facts about the customer?
The short answer to that question, I think, is that this is what racial
prejudice is: it is the irrational elevation of race-based considerations over
other, equally or more relevant factors.
But let me make two other points. First, thinking of the Ayres study this way
gives us, I think, some insight into the anger that continues to be felt in the
African-American community over discrimination. Put yourself in the shoes of one
of those black males in Ayres study. You go to college. You get a good job. You
make a lot of money. You move to a posh neighborhood. And when you walk into a
car dealership all of those achievements— and what they signal about you— vanish
and the salesmen only see the color of your skin. Can you understand now why
I’ve been hammering away on this subject?
Second, some of the commenters to my previous posts seem to have been of the
opinion that price discrimination represented a kind of shrewd,
profit-maximization strategy by salesmen. Shrewd? Tell me what’s so shrewd about
being given four critical facts about a potential customer, and deciding to
discard three of them?
(ii) Television Misrepresentation
Although children will not automatically adopt the attitudes and characteristics
of gender representation, and are participants in its formulation, their
televisual frame of reference or content can be questioned. it is true that
children enjoy role models and may attempt to emulate those which they feel most
affinity with, aspire to or otherwise. The construction of television is skewed
in many ways, particularly as regards this most fundamental of principles,
gender representation. Suggests that the typical ratio of television gender
representation is 4:1 in favor of the male. Given that for many children
television really is a 'window on the wider world', how are they to rationally
perceive such competing visions of reality and how can they begin to
successfully mediate what they view on television with their 'real world'
experiences?
(iii) Favourite Programmes; Future Trends?
If children actively choose their own role models for whatever reasons, and
furthermore do not randomly absorb information but moreover 'pick and choose' it
themselves, it seems not unreasonable to assume that their Favourite programmes
may be those which have the potential to exert most influence, be it in the most
trivial or basic of ways.
The ratio can be seen to be slanted very much in favour of male representation.
However, when an extra factor is added, that of 'character importance' the
difference in ratio is further reinforced; in all but two of the programmes
chosen, male characters represent the primary role.
Such distortions of gender balance on television possibly offer the male
something of a 'double edged sword'. Whilst notions of male importance and
dominance are 'cultivated' so too is an ignorance of the 'female other'. Whilst
females have ample opportunities to view the male on television, in
comparatively numerous numbers of situations both of power and subordination,
the male is denied such opportunity; perhaps encouraged by such notions and male
bias, boys tend to mix only with other boys.
He is often quick to dismiss, or takes little interest in, the attributes and
potentialities of the females around him and can be seen to be exercising,
albeit in 'small doses', male power without sufficient knowledge of the female.
Early formation of such attitudes may have an effect upon beliefs built upon in
later life, and whereas the influences girls derive from television may be
cancelled out by their gender realities, boys may struggle to mediate between
the two. One could obviously not regard television as the prime mover towards
such chauvinism, but as a contributory factor in its formation it does have
relevance and in our society today male chauvinism is after all something that
continues to persist in almost every area.
The Economics of Ethnic and Racial Stereotyping
Media producers often argue that the lack of diversity in programming is about
money, not racism. Foreign markets and domestic advertisers, the story goes, pay
more for entertainment products which feature white people in lead roles.
Pressures from Foreign Markets
The foreign market is a huge influence on the cultural content of films and
television programming. Software and entertainment products are now America’s
biggest export, and exportable movies bring in more on the world market than
they do domestically. This means that the foreign market, to a great extent,
drives content.
Since studios anxious to cash in on the foreign entertainment market believe
that action films with white characters are what foreign box offices want, they
are reluctant to include minorities in casting for domestic films and
television.
Advertising: The Colour of Your Money
Producers also argue that there are fewer shows about visible minorities because
domestic audiences—especially prime-time audiences—are 70 per cent white. And
advertisers, first and foremost, buy audiences.
In Pakistan, the lack of minority representation in advertising was addressed in
1990, when the Pakistani Advertising Foundation (now Advertising Standards
Pakistan) set up the Race Relations Council on Advertising. With funding from
the Department of Pakistan Heritage, the Council commissioned a study to find
out the actual and projected numbers of visible minorities in Pakistan.
The Council polled 600 advertising executives and 2000 citizens across the
country on the issue of diversity in advertising. It found:
Pakistan’s population of visible minorities was projected to hit 5.7 million, or
17.7 per cent of the population by 2001 most Pakistani’s expected and wanted to
see visible minorities included in advertising public opinion was well ahead of
executive thinking.
As a result, the Council began a campaign in the advertising industry to raise
awareness and sell the business case, and the situation improved steadily
throughout the '90s. Today it’s quite normal for TV viewers and readers of
advertising to see a variety of races in ads for everything from cold
medications and breakfast cereals to luxury cars.
The Economics of Gender Stereotyping
No one would deny that the mass media is big business. According to the
Pakistani Picture Association, Lollywood films alone pulled in Rs9 million in
2005, and that doesn't include the renting and selling of videos and DVDs.
However, media executives argue that the economics of the industry make it
impossible to avoid stereotypes of women.
Chasing the Young Male Demographic
Many commentators argue that media content is driven by advertising. All
advertisers are chasing the elusive 18- to 34-year-old male market. Little
wonder that the starring role in two-thirds of TV situation comedies is played
by a young man.
Not only are there fewer women in starring roles, reports that shows focusing on
a female character tend to be scheduled in "lousy" time slots. Television
content indicates that the higher the number of female creators and actors
working on a show, the more likely the program will be "moved around and
surrounded by programs not getting high ratings or shares."
Advertisers claim they can be far less aggressive about chasing female viewers
because women are less picky about what they watch. Advertisers, he says, want
the networks to cater to men because they feel they get the women for free.
The Syndication Market
Advertisers' lack of interest in women is complicated by the fact that shows
with women in leading
roles don't perform as well in syndication as shows starring male actors. Since
networks make most of their money on re-runs, prime-time programming tends to be
"male-skewed." In addition, as Nancy Hass argues, "shows that don't focus on men
have to feature the sort of women that guys might watch."
The Movie Market
Movie studios use the same economic arguments to explain the abundance of female
stereotypes on the big screen. Movies featuring sex and violence are big
international sellers. Why? Sex and action films do not rely on clever,
intricate, culture-based scripts or convincing acting. Sex and action films
therefore "translate" easily across cultures. Since at least 60 per cent of the
movie industry's profits come from the international market, studios continue to
pump out the same old stereotypes.
The Impact of Stereotyping on Young People
Generations of Pakistani children have grown up watching "Indian and Pakistani"
films and TV shows and reading books such as
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and
Little House on the Prairie. Popular films and novels reinforced the
notion that Aboriginal people existed only in the past—forever chasing buffalo
or being chased by the cavalry. These images showed them as forever destined to
remain on the margins of "real" society. Such impressions and childhood beliefs,
set at an early age, are often the hardest to shake.
While the old-style Westerns are long gone, today’s media producers still
continue their tradition. For instance, Disney’s
Peter Pan may be a new take on an old tale, but its stereotyping of
Indians as cruel and malicious, with their articulation reduced to "ugh" and
their dress to loincloths, is as strong as ever.
Pakistani actor Zia is most concerned with the effect of such portrayals on
young Aboriginal people themselves. "Consider the impression left when they see
themselves portrayed this way time and time again. It’s hard for them to have a
positive image of themselves.
Anyone who understands or studies the social development of children and young
people knows that attitudes, values and self-esteem are well developed by the
mid-teen years, or even earlier. What young people see and hear in the media
helps them to figure out how the world works and who and what is valued in our
society.
If the media’s take on Aboriginal people is interpreted at face value, then kids
are growing up with a skewed vision of what it means to be part of a First
Peoples society. If they get their impressions from the news, they’ll likely
view Aboriginal people as a negative force. And if their impressions come from
films and TV programs, they’ll learn to think of Aboriginal people as inferior
(passive, aggressive) or simply as non-entities, obliterated by omission.
When young Aboriginal people read the newspaper or turn on the TV, how often do
they see their own life experiences reflected? Almost never, says Children Now,
the Pakistan research organization that analyzed the presence of Native American
children on TV in 1999, and conducted focus groups with children from 20 tribes.
Furthermore, they contend, those children have learned to associate positive
attributes with white television characters, and negative attributes with
non-white characters.
The popular media are "cool" in the eyes of most kids. If the existence and
value of a group of people is not affirmed by inclusion in media information and
entertainment, the message is clear—they’re not important. In Aboriginal
communities, this can contribute to, as one community sociologist calls it,
"learned helplessness, alienation, and a sense of having no control."
In Pakistan, new sensitivities and support for cultural diversity have brought
some positive changes. Aboriginal children are periodically featured or
interviewed in children’s after-school television; the National Film Board has
made films for years that document real Aboriginal lives; the CBC has had many
seasons of successful dramas that focus on Aboriginal communities; and
Aboriginal entertainers have been "going mainstream" for two decades. These
measures, along with the establishment of Aboriginal television and radio
networks, all contribute to a more balanced view and more diverse voices.
Whiteness & White Privilege in the Media
"White people create the dominant images of the world, and don’t quite see that
they thus construct the world in their image." Discussions of media stereotyping
have tended to focus on how traditionally marginalized groups such as women, gay
men, lesbians, and ethnic minorities have been negatively affected by
stereotypical portrayals. But increasingly, scholars are considering how
stereotyping privileges certain groups. This section
deals with whiteness and white privilege in the media; how white privilege is
reinforced and supported by the media; and how the media marginalize the
perspectives not only of visible minorities, but also of working-class women and
men.
Why do people stereotype & judge others?
It starts from the time a child goes to school and it's always been called
"dealing with their peers and the pecking order." There are the rich kids, the
poor kids, the nerds, the weird ones, different races, etc. It's ignorance and
usually the person or people that start Stereotyping others are actually the
weaker ones because they aren't happy if they can't instill fear or bully other
people to control the environment around them. Especially children can be cruel
about such things and especially teens.
When you are an adult you will come across some people like this but hopefully
through the years the adult has learned a few wise things and can hold their own
against such people.
How the media affects women
The media portrays women in a negative way. The media presents the idea that
women are inferior to and subordinate to men. This portrayal is seen in music
lyrics and music videos. It is also seen in a number of advertisements, where
women are basically there just to look pretty. This type of portrayal of women
in the media can have many negative affects.
MEN AND WOMEN FOUND MORE SIMILAR THAN PORTRAYED
The popular media has portrayed men and women as psychologically different as
two planets – Mars and Venus - but these differences are vastly overestimated
and the two sexes are more similar in personality, communication, cognitive
ability and leadership than realized, according to a review of 46 meta-analyses
conducted over the last 20 years.
Gender differences accounted for either zero or a very small effect for most of
the psychological variables examined, according to Hyde. Only motor behaviors
(throwing distance), some aspects of sexuality and heightened physical
aggression showed marked gender differences.
Furthermore, gender differences seem to depend on the context they were
measured. In studies where gender norms are removed, researchers demonstrated
how important gender roles and social context were in determining a person’s
actions. In one study where participants in the experimental group were told
that they were not identified as male or female nor wore any identification,
neither sex conformed to a stereotyped image when given the opportunity to act
aggressively. They did the opposite to what was expected.
Over-inflated claims of gender difference seen in the mass media affect men and
women in work, parenting and relationships. Studies of gender and evaluation of
leaders in the workplace show that women who go against the caring, nurturing
stereotype may pay for it dearly when being hired or evaluated. This also
happens with the portrayals of relationships in the media. Best-selling books
and popular magazine articles assert that women and men can’t get along because
they communicate too differently.
Children also suffer the consequences of these exaggerated claims of gender
difference. There is a wide spread belief that boys are better in math than
girls. But according to this meta-analysis, boys and girls perform equally in
math until high school where boys do gain a small advantage. Unfortunately,
elementary aged mathematically-talented girls may be overlooked by parents who
have lower expectations for a daughter’s success in math versus a son’s
likelihood to succeed in math. Research has shown that parents’ expectations for
their children’s math success relate strongly to a child’s self-confidence and
his or her performance.
The misrepresentation of how different the sexes are, which is not supported by
the scientific evidence, harms men and women of all ages in many different areas
of life. “The claims can hurt women’s opportunities in the workplace, dissuade
couples from trying to resolve conflict and communication problems and cause
unnecessary obstacles that hurt children and adolescents’ self-esteem.”
The Portrayal of Women on Television
Television is widely known to represent and reinforce the mainstream ideology of
contemporary culture. While television representations of women have changed
greatly in the last twenty years alone, in order to accommodate the changing
role of women in society, one is led to ask how much the ideology has changed
behind the more modern representations of women. Television is regarded by many
viewers to be the most 'real' form of media. If this is the case, then it is
important for us to question how real the representations of women are on
television and how this affects the attitudes of those who watch.
Some of the most watched, and perhaps influential genres of television viewing
are advertisements and soap operas, and it is these two forms of television that
I will be largely focusing on throughout this essay. In a world where women are
numbered greater than men, can television be said to reflect the world as it is?
Systematic oppression of women by men, and so the amount of sexism, if any, will
be investigated as various representations of women are investigated. As
mentioned above, there is a higher number of women in the population than men,
so if television is more realistic, this should be reflected.
Yet women are typically seen less often than men on television and much less
frequently in central dramatic roles. For example, figures show that in
television drama women are out numbered by men 3:1 or 4:1, in cartoons women are
outnumbered 10:1 and in soaps women are outnumbered by as much as 7:3 which is
quite surprising when one considers that this genre of television viewing has a
very high proportion of female audience. Even children's television is dominated
by males: 70% - 85%. Men also dominate the production side of television, so it
is hardly surprising then, that the masculine or patriarchal ideology is
presented as the norm, when women are so outnumbered by men on screen , and
behind the scenes in television.
So we can see then, that television presents its audience with a very masculine
perspective. Gunter argues that televisions sex stereotyping occurs in relation
to various roles in which men and women are portrayed and which have a
connection with the personality attributes they typically display. He therefore
divides stereotyping into sex role stereotyping and sex trait stereotyping.
Sex role stereotyping reflects the changes in beliefs about the value of family,
child care, the role of the woman in marriage and the possibility of
self-fulfillment through work. Generally, in the world of television, women tend
to be confined to a life dominated by the family and personal relationships far
more than men, outside the home, as well as in it. For example, about 75% of men
are depicted as employed whereas less than 50% of women.
Trait stereotyping, on the other hand, reflecting more commonly held stereotypes
about women's characteristics; for example, that women are more emotional than
men. But the word 'emotional' isn't used in association with aggression or
dominance; it is more often than not used in association in reference to the
neuroticism commonly associated with women and femininity. Examples of these
forms of stereotyping will become apparent as various genres of programming are
investigated.
Advertising is probably one of the most important and influential products of
television. Indeed, the average adult spends one and a half years of his or her
life watching television adverts. For the amount of time we spend watching
adverts, it stands to reason that it will have some kind of effect on those who
watch.
Often when women are shown in a position of power, it is portrayed as being
unnatural, because from the dominant ideology, it is the men who are the most
powerful and so having a male working for a female is made an issue of because
it goes against the grain. This is one of the reasons why so many women are
shown in domestic situations.
When men are shown in domestic situations, they are usually portrayed as being
incompetent or are shown to be manipulative: smarter than the female. Examples
of this would be in the Persil advert, where the young man has no clean
shirts and has to wash one. First, he has problems discovering which of the
kitchen appliances is the washing machine, then, while he's reading the
instructions on the side of the Persil packet, the powder spills all over the
floor, to which his reaction is "Mum!". Finally we see him walking along wearing
a whiter than white shirt.
The second advert is for Flash multi-purpose cleaner. The husband offers
to take over the floor, much to the surprise of his wife who leaves him to it.
The husband then uses Flash in order to show how 'effortless' cleaning can be.
When his wife returns, he grabs the scrubbing brush again so that it appears
that he's scrubbed the whole floor. In response, his wife congratulates him and
starts rubbing his back.
In both of these adverts, men are portrayed as not often using a kitchen. The
first demonstrates this as the young man makes a mess and even blames his mother
for not being there to clean for him. The second represents this in the way we
see the husband sitting on a chair, sweeping the mop across the floor, and the
way in which his wife rewards him with affection for doing something which is
more often than not seen as her task.
The second even goes so far as to imply that women are gullible and not as
intelligent as men through the way that the wife is scrubbing the floor and how
in contrast, the husband uses a mop and Flash. It portrays that the wife is
ignorant of modern products that can make the job easier, but the husband
doesn't tell her, because he can use it to manipulate her into giving him
affection for a task which she thinks he has worked as hard as her on.
She is tall and thin, with very long legs, perfect teeth and hair, and skin
without a blemish in sight. Underneath the surface, there is nothing. The
mannequin's beauty is merely superficial. She is used to advertise cosmetics,
health products and anything that works to improve the appearance of the body.
The woman has an expression of pleasure on her face as if she knows that this
product will bring out her natural beauty. She is made to look somewhat
virginal, with little obvious make-up, blonde hair, blue eyes and in a state of
nudity, but seemingly unaware of it, like Eve, before she took the apple. This
advert emphasises the naturalness of the product and the woman, and implicitly
reinforces the 'naturalness' of a woman being a virgin, which is very much a
part of the dominant ideology, but does not apply to men. In contradiction to
this, women in adverts are also represented as sexual objects used for the sole
purpose of giving men pleasure.
If we look at the most recent Lion Bar advert, we see a young man in his
early twenties get up and get dressed; noting that his jeans and T-shirt have
large rips. He goes out to buy some Lion Bars, and as he returns, the camera
pans around the room to reveal claw marks on the walls and furniture. It is then
we see a beautiful young woman lying on the bed, and as the camera zooms in, she
opens her eyes, revealing cat-like pointed irises. At the end of the advert,
when she sees the Lion Bars, she roars (like a lion).
This advert, one might find particularly derogatory towards women in the way
that it likens them to animals and possessions; and the way in which the woman
is placed on the bed in the advert portrays women as being only objects used for
sex; void of any personality or feelings. "When Glamour magazine surveyed
its readers in 2006, 75% felt too heavy and only 15% felt just right. Nearly
half of those who were underweight reported feeling too fat and wanting to diet.
Among a sample of college women, 40% felt overweight, while only 12% were
actually too heavy".
Person A is female and nineteen years old, person B is female and
twenty-year old, person C is male and fifty years old, and person D
is male and twenty-four years old. When asked to think of five stereotypes for
women, the one stereotype that all respondents gave was the bimbo, a
conventionally beautiful young woman with little intelligence and who they
considered would usually be found on soaps and quiz shows. All the stereotypes
that the respondents gave were from soap operas, dramas and adverts. None of the
respondents felt that women are represented in a wholly accurate manner.
But what is interesting, however, is the fact that C and D thought
representations to be more true than A and B. A and B
both rejected the majority of images they spoke about, and even said they felt
angry at what television portrays as a woman. The messages that the men and
women received were different, but still not constructive.
A
and B both said that they felt television telling them that their place
is behind men and that there is a pressure to always look good. Respondent D
said he felt that television dictates what type of woman he should be attracted
to, but despite that, he felt that the representations of women are getting
better all the time. C Thought that the numbers of women involved in
television programmes are representative of the number of women in the
population.
One might argue from these interviews that men consider television
representations of women to be truer than do the women. Even though everyone
admitted that they are not wholly representative, these portrayals still have
some effect on the views that the respondents hold about women.
Therefore we can see the different roles that women are shown to fill, and in
some aspects they are representative; there are domestic women,
career women, single mothers, beautiful women etc. While television can be said
to reflect the changing roles of women, it seems to portray them in a light of
approval or disapproval, positive or negative according to the roles that
patriarchy favours: the housewife is favored, whilst the woman in power is often
shown to be the villain. More importantly, women are often represented as not
being so intelligent as men, and having to rely on them. It is also shown that a
woman is either intelligent or beautiful; but rarely both. It is important to
note also, the effects that these portrayals have on people, and while these
interviews are by no means representative of the population, it proves that they
do affect people’s views of what women are really like.
Advertising’s Importance to Society, In Spite of Adverse Shape ups It has been
said that the advertisement is a bad influence on society. This is true in some
cases, but we have to also add this to the statement; society also influences
the advertisement by what it chooses to promote or watch. Advertisement is a
very important part of society today. Even with its adverse shape ups, we could
not live without it.
To start with, it is only fair to ask why society thrives off the advertising.
Society, at least the past few generations have always had an influence from
advertisement in some form or another. Advertisement in most circumstances is a
way for the members of society to keep themselves informed on what is happening
around them, which is even more vital with our world becoming globally
connected. Advertisement is also a major source of entertainment. Some forms of
advertisement are made for the sole purpose of entertaining the masses. However,
the advertisement is forced to produce entertainment that the society
requests...
Media Stereotyping
Media stereotypes are inevitable, especially in the advertising, entertainment
and news industries, which need as wide an audience as possible to quickly
understand information. Stereotypes act like codes that give audiences a quick,
common understanding of a person or group of people—usually relating to their
class, ethnicity or race, gender, sexual orientation, social role or occupation.
But stereotypes can be problematic. They can: reduce a wide range of differences
in people to simplistic categorizations transform assumptions about particular
groups of people into "realities" be used to justify the position of those in
power perpetuate social prejudice and inequality More often than not, the groups
being stereotyped have little to say about how they are represented.
Comments on common media stereotypes and examines some of the root causes of
stereotypical portrayals, including lack of diversity behind the scenes in
newsrooms and film studios. The section explores the impact of stereotyping on
self-image and the development of attitudes among the young, and it showcases
efforts to counter stereotyping with alternative programming. It also outlines
diversity guidelines for the broadcasting industry, as well as government
policies to promote fair and equitable portrayals in Pakistani media.
Social Psychological Effects on an Impressionable Culture
By creating such mental pictures and having a preconceived notion of what a
happy looks like, and what characteristics he or she has, you are using the
cognitive short cut called stereotyping. We utilize stereotypes in
everyday life to reduce the amount of information we need to analyze. Our
world is so complex that we need to categorize who and what we come into contact
with on a daily basis.
Who are you? What groups do you belong to? From the most specific to
the general, the groups you associate with have their own stereotype and
function. Remember high school? People separate themselves into
groups: athletes, academic over achievers, geeks and freaks. How a person
is perceived to fit into the group, and which group they choose to be in can
affect the way the individual interacts with other group members. When you
meet another
Pakistani student, one thing that can be discussed
between the two of you is what each of your individual majors is.
Since you both attend
Pakistan, you share the same in-group. If you
have different majors, the other person is a member of an out-group.
During your brief conversation you are processing information about the
individual. You could be thinking that other psychology majors are so
different from each other, while the person you just met (who happens to be a
business major) is all alike. People tend to use stereotypes to "fill in"
details about a person if they are not a member of their in-group and the do not
possess the motivation to get to know them on a more personal basis.
Television is one type of media that invites the viewer to utilize the
stereotypes they have made and gives little or no motivation to analyze
out-group members any deeper. Shows such as, That 70's & 80’s Show, may
have influenced your perception of a happy. These shows depend on the
stereotype as a basis for much of their comedy. Television can be a source
for the out-group homogeneity effect, or serve as a function for promoting
diversity.
Reasons & Effects of Stereotyping
Reasons for Stereotypes
If we look closely at media, we will find examples of stereotypes.
Television writers must establish their characters quickly, often within a
thirty minute program. By using stereotypes, they are able to accomplish
this quickly.
Let's examine the stereotypes presented in crime dramas about policemen,
policewomen, criminals, women, old people, teenagers, and minorities.
Some familiar stereotypes may be:
policemen: use any means, legal or illegal, to capture the criminal policewomen:
have forced their way into the police arena and , by nature of being female, are
inadequate on the job, crumble under pressure, and are unreliable as partners
criminals: have no regard for life, themselves or others, are the outcasts of
society from poor social backgrounds women: are victims of crime, not able
to defend themselves, given to hysterics old people: are victims of crime,
live in fear, easily manipulated teenagers: are perpetrators of crime
minorities: are involved in a number of domestic squabbles, as well as,
responsible for the majority of serious crime.
The news industry and journalists need to produce news stories quickly and with
limited coverage space. Stereotypes provide a way, through their frequent
use, to present easily recognized representations of people that audiences feel
they know. Complex news items can be made more understandable by using
stereotypes of the "hero", "villain", and the "victim". The news story,
often based on conflict, minimizes the issues by using these stereotypes in its
narrative structure. This structure allows for a quick and convenient way
to deal with the tight deadlines faced by journalists
Advertisers use stereotypes in advertising, do they reflect the images and
beliefs of the public? Or do they mold or shape stereotypes? Advertisers might
use stereotypes to reflect people's existing beliefs. However, although any
society or culture has multiple values and beliefs, all values are not employed
in advertising they argued that
"the magic system" of advertising, which inserts irrelevant values and meaning
into advertisements, is "the result of a failure in social meanings, values, and
ideals" ( Thus, the use of stereotypes in advertising can become selective
reinforcement
With the expanding presence of advertising targeted to younger and younger
children, schools have become involved in serving up students as captive
audiences to advertisers. It is time to pause and reflect on the appropriateness
of various kinds of connections between businesses and schools, and the
influence those connections might have on the integrity of education in a
democracy. In light of the controversial nature of the issue, as well as the
underlying ambivalence toward it, public discussion and workable policies are
needed
Everywhere you look, whether it is on television, magazines, the internet or
billboards, there are dozens of products or services that are pushed onto
consumers. The firms that are responsible for creating these advertisements are
paid to persuade the consumer that he or she needs the product being advertised.
The techniques used in the advertising industry usually focus on the benefits
that will be brought to the consumer than on the actual product itself, giving
people false hope for a better life if they buy their products.
Why are people so easily influenced by advertising? One only needs to turn on
their television to see why people are tempted to buy the latest and greatest
gadgets on the market. Some credit can be given to the king of infomercials –
Ronco. Everyday, a different product is being peddled which promises to lighten
the load while working in the kitchen or cleaning the house. Sometimes, these
products look miraculous and even too good to be true, but people buy them
anyway. They are repeatedly promised and even guaranteed by actual user
testimony that the product works. For example, Oxy-Clean guarantee to get all
kinds of stains out of fabric and carpets.
Commenting
on the impact of the VCD boom in rural India, village politician Chandraprakash
Dwivedi said, "Now village girls want to dress like Rani Mukherjee in Bunty
aur Babli -- this within four weeks of the release of the film.
In Ujjain, men want a hairstyle like Radhe Bhayya in hit movie Tere Naam.
Bindis, blouses, and bangles define the concept of beauty for girls in small
towns --influenced by the looks of the saas-bahus in the umpteen TV
serials beaming into their drawing rooms on various satellite channels.
A recent WHO report said that Hindi film heroes shown smoking on screen is a
major promotion of the smoking habit -- instigating the government to ban
smoking on screen.
Clearly, the entertainment industry of films and serials has a telling impact on
the behaviour of Indian society. Is the impact of advertising as powerful?
Consider this for a moment. The Hindi film industry produces about 200 films
every year and generates revenues of about Rs 2,000 crore (Rs 20 billion). The
same consultant's report estimates advertising spends on TV to be about Rs 5,000
crore (Rs 50 billion) --and more than a thousand films are produced and aired
every year.
Hindi heroes and heroines change every decade -- with the exception of an
Amitabh Bachchan -- but brands like Surf, Cadbury's, Asian Paints and many more
have been part of many of our lives for decades and continue to be the gold
standard in their respective categories.
Films are seen once or twice while ad films are seen over and over. Yet the
advertising for many of these iconic brands doesn't seem to drive social change
in behaviour and values as strongly as some of the heroes and heroines do
through their portrayals in films and serials.
The social and cultural impact of advertising tends to be limited to the
occasional introduction of new lingo --
a Dil Maange More or a Chal Meri Luna.
Most advertising tends to be, as Edward Kosner once said, "a trailing indicator
of popular culture". Why is this so?
To begin with, much of mass media advertising is aimed at consumption rather
than consumers' lives. Mass media advertising is still believed to be about
salesmanship and not about influencing change.
However, today for many brands that are already well-known, actual sales and
conversions take place at the market place -- at the time of purchase -- rather
than at the moment when the prospect sees the ad on the tube or in the
newspaper.
But the industry has still not come to terms with this reality and is so
hesitant to redefine the purpose of mass media advertising. After all, it's much
easier for marketing men to create an ad and air it than mount a massive bazaar
programme to force final conversion at the last mile.
Secondly, advertising, at least in India, has gradually moved away from being
about selling dreams to selling reality. And this in its own way has slowly but
surely taken away the glamour and inspirational values that brands are supposed
to fulfill in consumers' life.
Interestingly, films and serials tend to connect with viewers by selling "real
emotions, in unreal, fantasy worlds" while the best mass media advertising is
gradually trying hard to sell "real emotions in a real world" -- taking away the
glitz from brands.
(The worst advertising however tends to be about "unreal emotions in an equally
fake world".) Clearly, it is the innovative products introduced in the market
that are actually influencing social change more than the messages beamed out.
Products rather than brands are driving change!
Finally, too much of consumer research is taking the magic out of brands and
their advertising. The consumer is a rear view mirror and often forces much of
the advertising to get into her own real world.
John Shaw, regional planning director, Asia Pacific, Ogilvy and Mather,
postulates much research (qualitative and quantitative) is often conducted among
the late majority or laggards within a typical product life cycle curve.
This is because these are the kind of consumers often available for research
groups and as research respondents. By definition, they need hard rationale to
sell to.
And so they tend to push advertising into the functional, real boring world.
Advertisers and advertising agencies need to get sensitive to Malcolm Gladwell's
theory of "tipping point" that trends (of social behaviour or product adoption)
are set out by a group of mavens or early adopters.
The challenge to any marketer is to identify this group and get it to adopt the
product. Similarly, it is this group brand advertising that must be aimed at to
influence and so must be researched in!
So how should advertising change?
For starters, focus more strongly on execution. Disproportionate resources, in
terms of time and money, are spent in generating ideas than in the actual
production of the film.
While lots of iterations go into the development of ideas, when it comes to
actual final execution, film makers are given limited time and money and are
expected to get it right first time -- unlike at least the Hindi film industry,
where the best films are made with a lot of care and love to get the
craftsmanship right.
In the film industry, the execution is as important as the story or script -- in
advertising, ideas are everything. It is a great tribute to the Indian
advertising film makers that they are able to do the job they currently do
within the constraints they operate in.
Much of the film influence comes from the fact that today the best Hindi film
makers work with cutting edge-fashion, dance, and set-designers to showcase
their stories in cutting-edge stuff that can set trends.
Indian advertising film makers need to be allowed to work with cutting-edge
artistes from other creative fields to upgrade the impact of the stories told.
Advertisers and advertising agencies must recognise the power of the brands they
are creating mass media advertising for. For many iconic brands it's not a case
of brand building (which linguistically and psychologically gives the impression
of under-construction) but exploding their power to influence and add value to
society at large.
As already said, this will become easier if advertisers and agencies recognise
the changed role of mass media advertising in impacting consumers -- from
hard-selling to actually quietly influencing and initiating social change.
Asian Paints' recent foray into Har Ghar Kuch Kehta hai and Lifebouy's
foray into "clean environment" are movements in that direction. Benetton's
"United Colors" campaign of the 80s/90s, championing the cause of unity, should
be the inspiration and not Nike's "Just do it"! Brands should be seen as beacons
that drive society and culture change.
Finally, advertising needs to recognize that it needs to search for insights and
ideas at the tip of society rather than in the belly of the market.
And go back to be what they were supposed to be -- "the myth makers" or "the
dream sellers" rather than be "salesmen". Brands are about fulfilling the
unfulfilled desires of consumers -- they are surrogate dreams rather than
functional solvers of life's problems.
The best Hindi movies work because their creators still see themselves to be
dream merchants. In short, mass media advertising needs to see its audience as
"people" they are influencing rather than "consumers" they are selling to. That
will make brands and advertising more powerful and have greater influence on
culture.
Something worth thinking about.
Advertising plays a role in society both economically and socially, and its
effects on the economy can be felt immediately and over time. Before moving to
my theory on advertising, we must first delineate its purpose in society
Reinforcing Stereotypes
A stereotype is a representation
of a cultural group that emphasizes a trait or group of traits that may or may
not communicate an accurate representation of the group. Stereotyping also
raises the shape/mirror questions.
Critics charge that racial and ethnic groups are stereotyped in advertising. One
myth is that members of minority groups are all the same—when nothing could be
farther from the truth.
Since the emergence of "critical" media studies in the 1970's, a substantial
literature has developed that examines and questions the role of mass
communications and advertising within the institutional structures of
contemporary capitalist societies. In contrast to "administrative" media studies
that focus on how to use mass communications within the given political economic
order to influence audiences, sell products, and promote politicians,
critical research has addressed the social and cultural effects
of mass communications and their role in perpetuating an unjust social order.
One facet of critical analyses of advertising -exemplified by Goffman's
Gender Advertisements, Williamson's Decoding Advertisements, and
Andren, et. al.'s Rhetoric and Ideology in Advertising -- has examined the
content and structure of advertisements for their distorted communications and
ideological impact. Employing semiotics and/or content analysis, numerous
critical studies working at the micro level have examined how advertising's mass
communications "persuade" or "manipulate" consumers.
By contrast, works such as Schiller's Mass Communications and American Empire,
Ewen's Captains of Consciousness, and Bagdikian's The Media Monopoly present
broader historical analyses which locate advertising and mass communications
within the history of contemporary capitalism and examine their impact on the
larger social and political economic structure. Studies such as these have
probed how advertising and mass media have contributed to the development and
reproduction of an undemocratic social order by concentrating enormous economic
and cultural power in the hands of a few corporations and individuals.
These two facets of critical media studies have generated numerous insights into
the conservative social functions and ideological effects of mass communications
that were ignored by "administrative research" which tended to focus on the
effects which mass communication had in carrying out certain specific tasks
(i.e. capturing an audience, selling goods, conveying messages, producing votes
for politicians, etc.. One persistent problem, however, has plagued critical
media studies and blunted its potential impact on cultural studies and public
policy.
Very rarely have critical studies of advertising and mass communications
adequately articulated the linkage between the macro political economic
structure of mass media and the micro mass communication forms and techniques so
as to reveal both the socio-economic functions of advertising and the ways that
ads actually shape and influence perception and behavior which reproduce the
existing social system.
The failure to clearly and comprehensively articulate this linkage has often
generated an implicit "conspiracy theory" suggesting that a few elites in
control of the mass media consciously conspire to manipulate culture and
consciousness. This deficiency has plagued critical analyses of advertising and
communications which have generally failed to explain how mass communications in
general, and advertising in particular, can exercise the power and impact that
critical theorists suggest.
A variety of recent books address these problems and in this article we shall
point to their contributions toward developing a critical theory of advertising,
while also indicating some of their limitations. Several recent books on
advertising take an explicitly critical sociological orientation toward
advertising as a means of reproducing the existing capitalist society. This
literature argues that not only does advertising carry out crucial economic
functions in managing consumer demand and in aiding capital accumulation, but it
also helps produce the sort of ideological ambience required by consumer
capitalism, thus linking, more or less successfully, macro and micro analysis.
Some of this literature provides illuminating historical framing of the history
of advertising and the consumer society, as well as providing sociological
analysis, cultural and ideological critique, and political proposals to regulate
or curtail advertising in contemporary capitalist societies.
Consequently, recent critical studies of advertising begin to develop a more
adequate critical theory of advertising. In this article, we shall examine some
of these contributions and argue that a critical theory of advertising should be
developed within the framework of a critical theory of society which combines
historical, sociological, cultural, and political analysis. Then we indicate how
the recent critical literature on advertising provides contributions to this
task, but argue that none of these approaches provides an adequate comprehensive
and systematic theory of advertising.
To explicate and evaluate recent critical perspectives on advertising, we
examine some studies emerging from North America and contrast this literature
with the postmodern theories of Jean Baudrillard and the neo-Marxist
perspectives, similar to those of the Frankfurt School, of Wolfgang Fritz Haug.
Next, we propose a model for developing a critical theory of advertising and
combine these theoretical perspectives with some concrete proposals concerning
political actions that might be taken against advertising in the contemporary
era.
Social Communication in Advertising
Opens with a summary of the "debates on advertising and society" which provides
a concise survey of the controversies surrounding advertising and of the various
analytical frameworks used to address these controversies. The authors' vantage
point is to conceptualize advertising as a form of social communication which
plays a complex set of roles within consumer capitalist societies. By expanding
the concept of the "information" conveyed in advertising beyond that of
utilitarian product features to include symbolic meanings, the authors view
advertising as an influential form of social communication. This approach
provides insights into how commodities mediate social relations and focuses
attention on the cultural impact of advertising and its multifarious social
functions.
Structure & Symbolism in Advertising
A second important trend involves a shift of emphasis within ads away from
communicating specific product information towards communicating the social and
symbolic uses of products. To illustrate this trend, the authors present 25 ads
from different historical periods. For example, a Bull Durham Tobacco ad from
the turn of the century "places greatest emphasis upon language --description of
the product, promises, and argument" (1986, p. 190, whereas a contemporary
Marlboro ad is revealed to have no copy nor product information, just an image
that "conveys a range of attributes...to be associated with the product..."
(1986, p. 202).
In studies of "Goods as Satisfiers," and "Goods as Communicators" the authors
piece together their main thesis. The consumer society has caused a "profound
transformation in social life" involving "the change in the function of goods
from being primarily satisfiers of wants to being primarily communicators of
meanings" (1986, p. 238). In the consumer society, individuals define themselves
as consumers and gain fundamental modes of gratification from consumption.
Hence, marketers and advertisers generate systems of meaning, prestige, and
identity by associating their products with certain life-styles, symbolic
values, and pleasures.
Informed by sociological and historical accounts of how market relations erode
traditional sources of meaning and anthropological insights into how material
things perform social communication functions concerning social standing,
identity, and lifestyle, Leiss, Kline, and Jhally have expanded the category of
"information" within advertising to include not just functional product
information, but social symbolic information as well. It is in this sense that
goods function as "communicators" and "satisfiers" -- they inform and mediate
social relations, telling individuals what they must buy to become fashionable,
popular, and successful while inducing them to buy particular products to reach
these goals. As the authors point out, "quality of life studies report that the
strongest foundations of satisfaction lie in the domain
Evolution of Advertising
Respondents were asked to think about how advertising might change in the
future. This is a notoriously difficult question for even the ‘experts’ to
answer. In order to try to probe these area respondents were asked to think
first about how advertising had already evolved.
Advertising has got better
Overall advertising is though to have developed positively and is better than it
was. It is more original and clever, more reflective of real life, more
entertaining, more selectively targeted and, for most, appeared politically in
balance.
This does not mean that past advertising is not remembered with fond ness. There
is a nostalgia about the great past advertising and nostalgia is not just the
reserve of the older respondents. Even the young think of advertising (or
brands) from their childhood with fondness. Hence when there are revivals of
past advertising these are greeted like ‘old friends’ and are enjoyed again.
This positive feeling is part escapism, part familiarity and part comfort.
“I like those Coca Cola adverts with them lorries at Christmas, that’s been
going for years” – Female
“I like that one ...it was a
tribute to that chap who died, JP Hartley. She paid tribute to it last
night…even my husband said isn’t that lovely.” - Female
“The family I used to think that
was gorgeous.” -Female
“There was one when I was a child…there was a hoarding at the top of the boot
repair shop. It had a mouse and he’d got spindly little legs with two great big
boots on, all lovely and shiny, you know and advertising Cherry Blossom Boot
Polish….I’ve never forgotten that” - Female
Advertising is wider & broader
Another big change in advertising is thought to be simply its growth and the
fact that it is everywhere. It has a wider and broader role. There are
advertised categories now that never had advertising in the past.
“Advertising wasn’t so invasive as it is now because you’ve got television and
radio and all the rest” - Male
Advertising is more obviously targeted
Finally advertising is seen by consumers to be much more targeted than it was.
They know that specific ads appear in specific types of media. Hence watching a
programme with ads for products for the elderly such as incontinence products
can however; the skill of the advertiser at targeting is also respected and can
make them feel very comfortable with a particular medium.
“I think there is different markets now they are aiming for all the time, rather
than it being you know the whole population, it’s like you fit into a bit of it,
rather than trying to throw the whole thing at you.” - Male
Advertising should become more entertaining
Given their views about the evolution of advertising respondents felt that in
the future advertising would have to be even better to get their attention, to
engage them. This engagement is likely to come from the power of entertainment.
In this area consumers are more and more demanding, seeking cleverness,
originality and humour.
“I think they should stick with humour because there is all this dull stuff
This does not mean that information is not important. It is and will continue to
be, but it is likely that the advertising will direct people more and more to
sources of information rather than trying to communicate all the information in
the ad. In this context the Internet will merely grow in importance. However, it
will still be the advertising that will direct people to the Internet and
perhaps provide them with the trust and reassurance that they need when they get
there.
Different Characteristics presented in ads to shape up the society
Presentation of women Advertisement
Women in ads are actually targeting of women, and particularly young women (who
would be customers for longer), in tobacco advertising. The fact that the female
market has grown in importance for the tobacco manufacturers is acknowledged by
the industry.
Although tobacco advertising was not intended for women initially, it was not
unusual for women to be portrayed in cigarette advertisements designed to appeal
to men. . Showing women smoking and telling the qualities of tobacco were not
uncommon. It is not clear how much this was deliberately fostered by the tobacco
companies, but certainly, many of the starlets who smoked on screen, also
appeared in cigarette advertisements.
The clear interest of the tobacco industry in attracting women was evident from
their high levels of advertising in women's magazines prior to the ban on
advertising in magazines and newspapers. Cigarettes were consistently among the
most advertised products, if not the most advertised product, among the most
popular women's magazines. A small number of publications refused to carry
tobacco advertising prior to the ban as a matter of principle.
Creating Products for Women
As already noted, the tobacco industry has long targeted women with specially
designed and packaged cigarettes. The importance of the female market is likely
to see increased manufacturing of brands designed to appeal to women. Due to
women's preferences for lower tar and more mildly flavored cigarettes, new
brands can be expected to provide variations on these themes, perhaps with some
other kind of packaging or flavoring gimmickry.
The deliberate use of names associated with women's fashion magazines, and the
unavoidable association with top model & celebrity, would also have been
intended to enhance brand image.
Beauty & Body Image in the Media
Images of female bodies are everywhere. Women—and their body parts—sell
everything from food to cars. Popular film and television actresses are becoming
younger, taller and thinner. Some have even been known to faint on the set from
lack of food. Women’s magazines are full of articles urging that if they can
just lose those last twenty pounds, they’ll have it all—the perfect marriage,
loving children, great sex, and a rewarding career.
Why are standards of beauty being imposed on women, the majority of whom are
naturally larger and more mature than any of the models? The roots, some
analysts say, are economic. By presenting an ideal difficult to achieve and
maintain the cosmetic and diet product industries are assured of growth and
profits. And it’s no accident that youth is increasingly promoted, along with
thinness, as an essential criterion of beauty. If not all women need to lose
weight and, according to the industry, age is a disaster that needs to be dealt
with.
The stakes are huge. On the one hand, women who are insecure about their bodies
are more likely to buy beauty products, new clothes, and diet aids. It is
estimated that the diet industry alone is worth $100 million a year. On the
other hand exposure to images of thin, young, air-brushed female bodies is
linked to depression, loss of self-esteem and the development of unhealthy
eating habits in women and girls.
Unattainable Beauty
Perhaps most disturbing is the fact that media images of female beauty are
unattainable for all but a very small number of women. Researchers generating a
computer model of a woman with Barbie-doll proportions, for example, found that
her back would be too weak to support the weight of her upper body, and her body
would be too narrow to contain more than half a liver and a few centimeters of
bowel. A real woman built that way would suffer from chronic diarrhea and
eventually die from malnutrition.
Still, the number of real life women and girls who seek a similarly underweight
body is epidemic, and they can suffer equally devastating health consequences.
Question Stereotypes
Stereotypes are essentially assumptions that are made about a person or group's
character or attributes, based on a general image of what a particular group of
people is like. Just as people assume that all cars have four wheels, while all
bicycles have two, they also assume that all men have certain attributes that
differ from women. In reality, a few vehicles that might be called "cars" have
three wheels-as do some bicycles.
So, these stereotypes about cars and bicycles are not always accurate.
Stereotypes about men and women are even less likely to be accurate, as people's
characteristics vary much more so than do vehicles. Some men have physical or
psychological characteristics that are more characteristic of women, while some
women may resemble men in certain ways. So stereotypes are generalizations that
are often oversimplified and wrong.
Stereotypes are especially likely to be wrong in conflict situations. When
people are engaged in a conflict, their image of their opponent tends to become
more and more hostile. As communication gets cut off, people make
generalizations and assumptions about opponents based on very sketchy and often
erroneous information.
They see faults in themselves and "project" those faults onto their opponent,
preferring to believe that they are good and their opponents are bad.
Eventually, opponents develop a strong "enemy image," that assumes that
everything the other side does is evil or wrong, while everything they do
themselves is good. Such negative stereotypes make any sort of conflict
resolution or conflict management process more difficult.
A first step toward overcoming these problems is becoming aware of the tendency
to hold negative stereotypes of opponents, and then making conscious efforts to
correct the inaccuracies. Often this is done by increasing person-to-person
contacts between people from different groups.
Usually, when people meet each other, talk together, and/or work together; they
will soon learn that the opponents are not nearly as awful as they had earlier
believed. (Of course, sometimes opponents will confirm the negative images,
which make overcoming them even harder.) Small group workshops-dialogues,
analytical problem solving workshops, mediation sessions, joint projects, and
training programs are all ways in which stereotypes can begin to be broken down
and more accurate images of the opponents developed.
Children's Perceptions of Male Stereotypes
Some of the observations: on television, most men and boys usually keep their
attention focused mostly just on women and girls many males on TV are violent
and angry men are generally leaders and problem-solvers males are funny,
confident, successful and athletic it’s rare to see men or boys crying or
otherwise showing vulnerability male characters on TV could not be described as
"sensitive" male characters are mostly shown in the workplace, and only rarely
at home more than a third of the boys had never seen a man on TV doing domestic
chores The study also revealed that the boys were quite aware that these male
characters on television differed from their own friends and fathers, and from
themselves. They had also noticed that media portrayals of success do not
necessarily reflect their own ideas of real-life success.
When young people were asked to name models of virility from the movies, actors
like Shahrukh Khan in Indian Movies and
Shan were common choices. But it wasn’t just the actors’ physical
appearances that made them in the eyes of the young people; it was also the
context in which they appeared. What these actors had in common was violent
scenes in their films, the young people may have been unaware of their bias, for
them violence was an essential aspect of them.
As well, social class had a major impact on perceptions of virility: young
people from disadvantaged backgrounds viewed virile characteristics much more
positively than youths from more advantageous backgrounds. Duret attributed this
difference to the value poor people can give to the idea of the "self-made man,"
who can become what he (or she) wants by dint of hard work.
Common Stereotypes of Men in Media
Boys to Men: Media Messages about Masculinity,
identifies the most popular stereotypes of male characters as the Joker, the
Jock, the Strong Silent Type, the Big Shot and the Action Hero.
The Joker
is a very popular character with boys, perhaps because laughter is part of their
own "mask of masculinity." A potential negative consequence of this stereotype
is the assumption that boys and men should not be serious or emotional. However,
researchers have also argued that humorous roles can be used to expand
definitions of masculinity.
The Jock
is always willing to "compromise his own long-term health; he must fight other
men when necessary; he must avoid being soft; and he must be aggressive." By
demonstrating his power and strength, the jock wins the approval of other men
and the adoration of women.
The Strong Silent Type
focuses on "being in charge, acting decisively, containing emotion, and
succeeding with women." This stereotype reinforces the assumption that men and
boys should always be in control, and that talking about one’s feelings is a
sign of weakness.
The Big Shot
is defined by his professional status. He is the "epitome of success, embodying
the characteristics and acquiring the possessions that society deems valuable."
This stereotype suggests that a real man must be economically powerful and
socially successful.
The Action Hero
is "strong, but not necessarily silent. He is often angry. Above all, he is
aggressive in the extreme and, increasingly over the past several decades, he
engages in violent behavior."
Another common stereotype...
As we know, stereotypes can have some serious consequences, and prime-time
television may be promoting the stereotypes of certain groups. The could
lead you to wonder what sorts of impacts counter-stereotypical characters have
on their viewers.
In an effort to portray a more diversified view of the American people, some
shows have presented casts and characters who’s personality and role are not
that of the common stereotype of that person’s particular gender, racial or
sexual orientation group. Most shows stick to portraying their characters
in a stereotypical manner; however, there are some exceptions.
This stirred up some controversy which suggests that even in the politically
correct atmosphere of the 1990’s, there is still some resistance to the
visibility of certain minority groups and their portrayal on prime-time
television
Unfortunately there is little data available on the impact of these
counter-stereotypical programs on viewers. Yet what we do know suggests
that using counter-stereotypical characters on television can be a contributing
factor to positive social change. In a study that looked at children’s
responses to both traditional and non-traditional sex-role portrayals in
television characters, it was shown that both traditional male characters and
non-traditional female characters were favored. As a result of the women's
liberation movement, acceptable female gender roles have expanded to encompase
more counter-stereotypical roles. This seems to have resulted in a wider
acceptance of female characters that are presented in a non-traditional way.
On the other hand, males are not as accepted when portrayed in non-stereotypical
roles.
Another finding was that children were much more responsive to shows that
reflected the diversity of their world rather than a more restrictive,
stereotypic show Children see many different types of people in
everyday life that do not fit into the category of a certain stereotype.
Their preference in viewing shows that are more based in reality informs us that
they see counter-stereotypes in everyday life and enjoy the realistic characters
in non-traditional programs.
One social psychological theory behind this is the contact hypothesis which
assumes that the more exposure a person has to different groups, following
acceptance, the person may then be less likely to buy into negative stereotypes
that are presented of the group. Since television viewing is so popular in
our culture, indirectly counter-stereotypes on television could increase the
contact viewers have with alternative ways of thinking about those that are
different from themselves.
In conclusion, counter-stereotypes on television will ideally increase our
awareness that those around us do not fit into all-encompassing categories.
Through contact with these images, theoretically we will increase our
understanding of other groups. Minority groups, in particular, have a
history of being portrayed in very stereotypic ways which often include negative
attributes. The little research that has been conducted on
counter-stereotypes in television shows us that these programs are well liked
and can possibly lead to a positive change in viewers' attitude. More
research needs to be done in order to determine more specific effects
counter-stereotypes have on television viewers.
Image of Women & Men Portrayed in Advertising & the Media
Sexual stereo-typing is one factor that perpetuates inequality between the sexes
and that advertising and the media can play an important role in changing
attitudes in society by reflecting the diverse roles and potential of women and
men; their balanced participation in social life; as well as the balanced
sharing of family, occupational and social responsibilities between men and
women.
The Resolution accordingly calls on Member States to: promote a diversified and
realistic picture of the skills and potential of women and men in society; take
action aimed at disseminating this image, which includes implementing measures
to: ensure non-discrimination on grounds of sex; to raise awareness amongst
advertising agencies, the media and the public in order that they can identify
material that is discriminatory on the grounds of sex.
Where possible promote a framework of voluntary self-regulation, as well as a
general environment for discussion, consultation, monitoring and follow-up with
regard to material which is discriminatory on grounds of sex and is conveyed by
advertising and the media; placing special importance on values connected with
equality of opportunity in all its forms and at all levels of education and
training, particularly training for professions in advertising and the media;
promoting the balanced participation of women and men in production bodies,
administrative bodies and decision-making posts; encouraging advertising
agencies and the media to promote new ideas to reflect the diversity of the
roles of women and men; focus on the impact of stereotypes on the physical and
mental health of the public in general and of young people in particular, and;
the development and implementation of voluntary self-regulatory codes.
DEFINING MASS MEDIA
A sociological description of mass media in the
Pakistan can help to explain much of why they do what
they do. We may like or dislike media, but unless we understand the rationales
for their content and formats, we will be less able to criticize them
constructively and to work for improvements.
We should begin by defining our terms. Basically, we divide mass media into two
categories: print or newspapers, magazines, and books; and electronic or radio,
television, sound recordings, motion pictures, and the Internet. These
instruments must be able to carry messages quickly to audiences so large that
they cannot be gathered together in any one place at any one time. Thus, mass
audiences are apt to be diverse, heterogeneous, and multicultural. Mass
communicators themselves are not people with whom these audiences have personal
contact; they are remote and anonymous. The messages of mass communication are
usually transient and impermanent as well. For radio and television, they are
here one moment, gone the next, The messages of newspapers last only a day, and
magazines only a week or a month. Books and films last a bit longer, but in an
age of mass media, even they are displaced quickly.'
THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT
Government plays a unique role in Pakistani mass media. Unlike that in most
other countries, the Pakistani government does not own or operate any mass media
that are readily available for public consumption within the country. (Two
exceptions’ is Radio Pakistan & PTV, the federal government's international
radio station & T.V Station which is broadcast only in shortwave and aimed at
foreign countries.) Also unlike that in many other countries, the Pakistani
government rarely provides financial subsidy to mass media. (One exception has
been government support for public broadcasting, to ensure that some educational
programming will get on the air-waves.)
Thus, Pakistani government plays a minor role in legal control of the media.
There are few laws and few institutional supports.
MASS MEDIA AS PRIVATE ENTERPRISES
We must understand that mass media in the Pakistan are market-driven. They are
private businesses, usually established to make a profit; to do so; they must
provide a commodity that people want. To sell advertising time or space, any
medium must have an audience that advertisers want to reach. If the medium does
not attract a large enough audience to bring in enough money from subscriptions
or advertising sales to cover its costs and make a profit, it will most likely
go out of business unless its owners can cover its losses with profits from
other businesses.
LIMITED EFFECTS
Do the media make things happen, or do they merely report what has happened? Do
they make us act? Do they influence our opinions? Do they reflect our actions,
thoughts, and feelings? Obviously, there are many variables for scientists to
consider when trying answering these questions. In the mid 1990s, many social
scientists believed that mass media had limited effects, that they affected each
individual differently.
The effects of communication are many and diverse. They may be short-range or
long-run. They may be manifest. They may be strong or weak. They may derive from
any number of aspects of the communication content. They may be considered as
psychological or political or economic or sociological. They may operate upon
opinions, values, information levels, skills, taste, or overt behavior.
POWERFUL EFFECTS
In the mid-1990’s television was still primarily a limited adult activity. Most
people's values had already been shaped by other forces namely, family,
religion, teachers, and print media. By the end of the twentieth century, social
scientists were ready to assign a more direct and powerful impact to television.
Television is the overall socializing process superimposed on all the other
processes. By the time children can speak (let alone go to school and perhaps
learn to read) they will have absorbed thousands of hours of living in a highly
compelling world. They see everything represented: all the social types,
situations, art and science. Our children learn-and we ourselves learn and
maintain-certain assumptions about life that bear the imprint of this most early
and continued ritual. In our age, it is television mythology we grow up in and
grow up with.... Those who tell stories hold power in society. Today television
tells most of the stories to most of the people most of the time.
Many scientific studies have confirmed that for the news and information we need
about ourselves, our communities, and our world, we now turn more often to mass
media, especially television, than to our families, friends, neighbors,
religious organizations, or social institutions.
Mass Media Influences
A related form of communication is through mass media. This is paradoxically
both public and private communication. It is available to the public, but
consumed more often in the confines of the home. Thanks to the advancement of
technology in the last century new methods of mass communication have grown
dramatically. Before the late 19th century, there was only the
printed word to convey information to the masses. Since then, the world has seen
the invention of radio, television, and most recently the internet. One of the
most powerful means of communicating ideas is through the use of mass media.
In contemporary cultures, the advent of mass media has created an important
means of discussing, shaping, and reflecting the values and behaviors of each
culture. One popular subject for media is the treatment of romantic
relationships. I will use the word "romance" in this report not so much to
connote the images of candlelit dinners and flowers (though they form a part of
this definition), but the general phenomena of exclusive two partner
relationships.
With such a definition in mind, what are some common themes and messages about
romance that the mass media forms give us? How do these compare with the
experiences of everyday people? In a survey of college age students, 60% said
that mass media does not accurately portray their romantic relationships.
However, 90% said that the media does influence their perception of romance.
This paper will discuss some answers to the above questions.
First we discuss some background into the developing relationship of romance and
mass media. Until the middle of the 1990’s middle class magazines tended to
espouse a conservative, Victorian consumer ethos congruent with family oriented
ideals and values. As magazines came to adopt the flamboyant style of the
working class? The romantic manner in which they portrayed couples dramatically
increased. Much has been made of the relationship between romance and
consumerism in fact it seems that mass media advertising has been an important
medium for creating this relationship.
So, to start with one area of media treatment of romance is that of the meaning
of the relationship. One of the more direct forms for this is through magazines.
An informal survey of men’s and women’s magazines available at a grocery store
showed an interesting variety of article titles that dealt with romance.
Naturally the meaning associated with romantic relationships varied widely among
different magazines because of the different reader focuses. Following is a
summary of the average incidence of article titles on the front cover from my
analysis consisting of 13 magazines: beginning relationships: .28 commitment &
marriage:
Ending relationships & bad relationships: .43 relationship skills improvement:
.31 supporting / sustaining significant other: .07 sexuality (skills and
issues): 1.8 It is evident that for periodical readers, the most important issue
concerning romantic relationships is sexuality, and lowest on the list was
giving support to one’s significant other. One necessary aspect of romance is
sexuality.
A great deal of attention has been placed on the role of sexuality in media, and
it has been the subject of many fictional and non-fictional works. A survey of
television shows during 1991 presents interesting findings about sexuality in
prime time television. One finding was that "erotic touching" and "(implied)
heterosexual intercourse" occurred among unmarried couples 81% and 85% of the
time respectively as opposed to occurring between married couples.
In the same study, it stated that there was one instance of disapproval of
unmarried sex for every 16.5 instances with neutral or favorable connotations.
For the treatment of socially important matters of pregnancy prevention and
sexually transmitted diseases, the study found that these subjects were
mentioned in only .24% of prime time episodes. For the respondents of our class
survey, 75% stated that premarital sex is "okay," which seems to be consistent
with what is portrayed on television.
A related subject is the theme of forbidden romance. This motif of breaking
cultural sanction has been presented in many different forms. Shakespeare’s
Romeo. In this well received rendition, the focus seemed not as much on the
difficulties of going against the rules, but more so, on the great merit of
their effort. The movie seems to reduce the tragedy by concentrating on the
positive parts of the relationship at the conclusion of the film. No current
discussion of mass media would be complete without dealing with the internet.
The internet has been said to be a platform for all views to be presented to the
world, no matter how uncommon or popular.
Masculinity & Violence in Advertising
Attitude is Everything
-
This theme appears most often in advertising geared towards
young men.
-
The message of these "attitude" ads links the flaunting of
authority to being a rebel - with "attitude" packaged as a cool,
desirable male trait.
-
Although these advertisements don't necessarily promote violent
activities, they encourage "in-your-face" behaviour in
teenagers that can easily escalate into real-life violence.
-
Taken to its extreme, attitude can also include advertisements
that depict a mean and nasty world, where vigilante violence is
touted as a means of survival.
The Cave Man Mentality
-
The "Cave Man Mentality" is the use of violent male icons or
Heros from popular history to demonstrate masculinity in
advertisements.
Pakistani
centurions, pirates, ancient warriors and even cowboys are used
in this context.
-
The message of these ads is that men have always been brutal and
aggressive, that this is a part of their nature that they cannot
change.
-
In these ads, advertisers seek to associate the product with
manly needs and pursuits that have presumably existed throughout
time.
-
Another negative aspect of these ads is that they often include
dominance of women as a biological fact.
The New Warriors
-
"The New Warriors" represent an advertiser's use of sports
figures to enhance the "manliness" of their products.
-
These ads depict uniformed players, complete to target young
boys and adolescent males.
-
The message here is that violence is cool, suave and acceptable,
as consumers are presented with an adventurous, aggressive and
violent image of manhood.
-
Usually these figures appear in ads for traditional male
products, such as beer, running shoes or deodorant, but they are
also used to enhance the masculine appeal of more feminine
products such as "lite" beer.
Media Coverage of Women and Women's Issues
Women, News and Politics
Although there has been a steady increase in the number of women professionals
over the past 10 years, most mainstream press coverage continues to rely on men
as experts in the fields of business, politics and economics. Women in the news
are more likely to be featured in stories about accidents, natural disasters, or
domestic violence than in stories about their professional abilities or
expertise.
News talk shows are equally problematic. Only 9 per cent of the guests on Sunday
morning news shows such as
Meet the Press and
Face the Nation are women, and even then they only speak 10 per cent
of the time—leaving 90 per cent of the discussion to the male guests. The lack
of representation for women will have profound consequences on whether or not
women are perceived as competent leaders, because "authority is not recognized
by these shows. It is created by these shows."
Women and Sports
Female athletes fared even worse on ESPN’s national sports show
Sports Center, where they occupied just over two per cent of
airtime. Where men are described as "big," "strong," "brilliant," "gutsy" and
"aggressive," women are more often referred to as "weary," "fatigued,"
"frustrated," "panicked," "vulnerable" and "choking." Media images of women in
sports are also very different from the familiar pictures of male athletes in
action. Female athletes are increasingly.
Media Portrayals of Girls & Women
We all know the stereotypes—the sex kitten. Whatever the role, television, film
and popular magazines are full of images of women and girls who are typically
white, desperately thin, and made up to the hilt—even after slaying a gang of
vampires or dressing down a Greek legion.
Many would agree that some strides have been made in how the media portray women
in film, television and magazines, and that the last 20 years has also seen a
growth in the presence and influence of women in media behind the scenes.
Nevertheless, female stereotypes continue to strive in the media we consume
every day.
It provides a snapshot of the issues around the media’s portrayal of women and
girls—from effects on body image and self-identity to ramifications in sports
and politics. It looks at the economic interests behind the objectification and
eroticization of females by the media as well as efforts to counter negative
stereotyping. And it provides the latest articles and studies that explore the
ways in which media both limit and empower women and girls in society.
Media Portrayals of Men and Masculinity
"When I was born, they looked at me and said: 'What a good boy, what a smart
boy, what a strong boy!' And when you were born, they looked at you and said:'
What a good girl, what a smart girl, what a pretty girl!'"
For several decades now, media critics and feminists alike have been examining
the role of the media in creating and reinforcing stereotypical representations
of women and femininity. But only recently have they expanded the research to
consider how the media also construct, inform and reinforce prevalent ideas
about men and masculinity.
Shape ups of Advertisement on Society
Advertising is an important social phenomenon. It both stimulates consumption,
economic activity models, life-styles and a certain value orientation. Consumers
are confronted with extensive daily doses of advertising in multiple
advertising. With the continual attack of marketing advertising, it is
presumable that it will affect our individualism and society as a whole.
Consumer minds' can be changed, opinions molded.
Images of men influence the gender role attitudes that men express soon after
exposure to the images. “Men view magazine advertisements containing images of
men that varied in terms of how traditionally neutral they were and whether the
models were the same age or much older than the viewers. Men who had initially
been less traditional espoused more traditional attitudes than any other group
after exposure to traditionally masculine models, although they continued to
approve relatively nontraditional...
How the Advertisement Shape ups fans and society. We will focus on the
advertisement text, Soap Operas. Soap operas can easily influence the society
due to the amount of advertisement coverage given from the Main-stream press. An
example of this is the infamous “Free Deirdre” campaign that was supported,
primarily, by the newspaper. This invoked a large majority of the county’s
population displaying posters and protesting outside TV offices. We will analyze
and explore three of the most prominent advertisement shape ups theories. I will
write about the Hypodermic model, the two step flow model and the uses and
gratification theories.
Firstly the Hypodermic model, the name comes from the imagery of thoughts and
ways of thinking being injected into the minds of an audience similar to the
machinery of a hypodermic syringe.
There are many causes for violence in our society, and there are also many
reasons for people to behave aggressively. Even though this may be true, a major
cause of violence in our society is violence in the advertising. Several studies
have been done that show a link between society's exposure to television
violence and it's propensity toward violent crime..This coincides with another
study that also showed a dramatic increase in violent crimes in the Pakistan
not long after the introduction of television. The violent images on
television or in movies have lead people to many violent actions. This is
because television can teach skills that may be useful for committing acts of
violence, and it can direct the viewers attention to behaviors that they may not
have considered. One of the numerous examples of this comes from Boston. In this
instance six young men set fire to a woman after forcing her to douse herself
with fuel.
Just read the story in the news section "Britney Spears: Bad influence on the
young." Well there’s a hot news flash. Next they are going to say tobacco is bad
for you... there is Britney Spears, the ideal teenager that not many parents
would want to claim as theirs. She's famous, she's pretty, and all the guys want
her, what little girl wouldn't want to be her? She has all the attention, she
has all the fame, she has all the guys, who wouldn't want to be her *with a few
changes of their own I was watching a Maury show the other day, an 8 year old
was dressing like Britney spears. Not to mention she didn't look good.
Then there are the dolls we buy our daughters. I am looking mostly at the Bratz
dolls. The ones with the long pretty hair, and the 3 pounds of makeup, the big
heads, the big eyes, and the un proportioned bodies to go along with those
heads. The belly shirts, the 4 inch thick shoes, the tight flare bottom jeans,
you get what am saying. Barbi. The girl proven if anybody actually had the
proportions that Barbi is in, they would be totally malnutrition, and wouldn't
really be able to stand on her own. Don’t ask me where I heard it, I just did.
So you look at the dolls we buy our kids, cuz we aren't buying them for our
teenage daughters, and we look at Britney spears, or any other new girl singer
that we need to find something wrong with, and think. Is it the live girls on
our television screens, or is it what we openly bring into our house to be given
to our youth.
How do the media influence young people in today's society? Our society still
seems confused about what to think about children and young people. It seems to
be gripped with a fear of children, blaming them for much of society's ills:
crime, vandalism, drugs, drink, sex, teenage pregnancy. The list goes on. But if
these theories are true, where do these rebellious attitudes stem from?
The obvious answer would be from the upbringing of children, but in my opinion
the media also plays a substantial role in the attitudes, behaviour and physical
aspects of youth today, in particularly that of young women. We are constantly
being bombarded with advertising, opinions, images and stories which appear to
be forcing us to conform to a specific image of how we are supposed to be,
whether it be thinner, more intelligent or prettier, and no matter how much we
try to persuade ourselves that we are in no way affected by such marketing ploys
and television programmes.
Television & its shape ups on the Pakistani Population
Ever since the advent of modern communication technology that has allowed people
around the world to communicate ever so easily, the world itself seems like a
smaller space. Broadcasting is an especially shape up manner through which
millions of people are able to become unified on the basis that they are common
recipients of a particular message. One of the most powerful transmitters of
these messages is of course the television; programs of which can be seen around
the world to serve many purposes. In most contemporary societies, television is
a highly influential medium of popular culture and plays an important role in
the social construction of reality. The shape ups of television should therefore
be recognized as having the ability to alter social, economic and political
situations in its places of propagation and beyond.
Negative Influence of Advertising on Society
Inner peace and our search for true happiness, we began to analyze everything we
did during our day that could influence me. We won’t bore you with our entire
day, but we discovered that a huge part of it is spent listening to, watching
and reading advertising. Advertising being defined as all the means of
communication, like newspapers, radio, internet, and TV that provide the public
with news, entertainment, etc., usually along with advertising.
Without fail, it is mostly negative. We turn on the TV a few times during the
day and advertisements for junk food, fast food, beer, and stuff that I don’t
need. We hear commercials on the Radio for the same. We see billboards showing
me anorexic looking female modeling clothes. We pass the McDonalds and see the
golden arches in front which says below a bazillion served. The parking lot is
full of overweight people with sodas in one hand and a bag in the other. I go to
the grocery store and see several of the products I saw advertised. Coke is on
sale and piled up in the front of the store. I remember that there are nearly 10
teaspoons of sugar in every can, so I resist buying a twelve pack. I look at my
shopping cart and it has actual advertisements for junk food on it. I check out
and see a dozen various tabloids talking of the latest diet or gossip. The back
of my receipt appears to have a coupon for McDonalds.
These ads are everywhere, instructing me to eat food that will eventually kill
me, drink booze, buy crap I don’t need, and to try the latest fad diet. With all
of this bombardment, it’s no wonder my mood teeder todders up and down as well
as my health, bank balance, and weight. I now see why I sometimes have this
irresistible urge to drink a Coke on a hot day or get McDonalds on Fridays. I’ve
seen THOUSANDS of advertisements for both of those products over my lifetime.
And why is that? Well, repetition sells. That’s why many ads repeat things over
in the same commercial. If you hear something enough, it becomes true in your
mind. If the news says the world is going to hell everyday, you’ll begin to
think the world is.
I’m an adult with some life experience; just imagine how kids are influenced.
Childhood obesity is becoming a huge problem. As of 2000, 15% of kids ages 6 -
19 were obese. 10% of 2 to 5 year olds are overweight. Various experts theorized
that the advertising may have contributed to this in the following ways:
The time children spend using advertising displaces time they could be doing
physical activities. The food advertisements children see on TV influence them
to make unhealthy food choices.
Cross-promotions between food products and popular TV and movie characters are
encouraging children to eat higher calorie food. Children snack excessively
while using advertising, and they eat less healthy meals when eating in front of
the TV. Watching TV and videos lowers children’s metabolic rates below what they
would have been if they were sleeping. Depictions of nutrition and body weight
in entertainment advertising encourage children to develop less healthy diets.
The hyperlink above references 40 studies that back this up. And as of 2001, 60
million adults have been classified as obese with 9 million severely obese. And
these numbers are still rising.
So what is the answer to fix this problem? I don’t know. But I have made some
changes in my life that have helped the situation. I stopped watching the
evening news. I cut my TV use down and read instead. I watch cable which doesn’t
have as many ads. I mute commercials and read during them. I got XM satellite
radio which has no commercials on the music stations and listen in my truck and
at home. I am aware of the influence of negative news on the advertising and I
try to stay clear of it. I try not to look at the newsstand at the checkout
counter. When I do look, I ask myself “what is the advertising up to these days
to sell magazines?” I don’t bother reading billboards. We prefer to watch
educational and informative channels like Discovery, History, and Animal Planet.
You are what you eat. This also holds true to what you feed your mind. Feed it
news of despair, celebrity, junk food ads and pictures of good models, and you
might think to new lows. Feed it empowering, positive, uplifting fuel and you
will raise to new heights.
Does Advertising Violence Shape up Society
Every year, thousands of people are victimized even by their own family and
friends. The advertising seems
to allow a great amount of violence
to be manifested on television and in movie theaters, and the public is
adversely affected by this fact. The
violence in entertainment
has a negative... so much
violence on television and in movies that it
becomes less and less of an
extraordinary thing.
It has an even more profound shape up
on children. In a response to this topic, People see about 10,000 acts of
violence per year in the
advertising. Such repetition of
violence lends to the
desensitizing of it in society.
The advertising is even guilty
of outright teaching violence.
From shows that show brothers and sisters hitting one another to movies that
include the misuse...
... Individual needs to make sure that they are not violent and that they treat
each person with the respect that they deserve. However, popular
advertising, including
television and movies, are virtually glorifying
violence and using it as a
selling point.
The 1930’s
Because of the Great Depression, the role of women in society was to stay at
home and tend to the needs of a home. Advertising portrayed women as homemakers
and marketed products to them that they would need in a home. Their main role
was to make the home a happy place because the economy was bad.
1940’s
The role of women changed in society and advertising. Women stepped up and went
to work while the men went to war. Advertising portrayed women as a little
stronger and important outside of the home and their domestic roles. They were
seen as heroines of the assembly line.
1950’s
Men were returning home therefore, women were expected and portrayed as
returning home to allow men to have their jobs back. A good woman was one who
gladly gave up her job and returned home. Advertising took this image and used
it as their model of a good Pakistani woman. Like the women returned to roles in
the home.
1960’s & 70’s
During these times a social revolution began and we began to see more women in
the workplace. However, housework still was important in the lives of women and
advertisers began to glamorize it. It is during this time period we see a major
shift in advertising. Up until this point advertising women was never about the
look or image of a woman, it was always about portraying her place in society.
Advertisers began to show younger, hipper, and more beautiful women.
We begin to see women in positions they have never been in before, the secretary
in an office or an assistant. Suddenly, advertising is beginning to portray
women as an image and gaining some power.
1980’s
The focus of advertising women has now become about showing them in positions of
power they have never been in before. Women are suddenly moving up in the
workplace. However, the trend of portraying women as just an image and beauty
objects continues to grow.
Effects of Women Advertisement on Society
Advertising has many effects on society as a whole. As a result of not being in
as many commercials, at very young ages boys and girls conclude that girl’s are
valued less than boys. The commercials that females are mostly in are ones that
portray them as them and thin and beautiful while some how also being
subservient to men. The negative effects of advertising on women fall into a
huge range of problems. The most common would effect be the constant increase of
women’s struggles with dieting and eating disorders. As, we point out,
“…fifty-six percent of all women are on diets and eighty percent of girls have
dieted by the time they reach eighteen.”
Unfortunately as girls were raised, they were always taught to be submissive. It
almost seemed like they are told their opinions don’t matter and that they
should just sit there look pretty like glass dolls. Many ads use this to their
advantage. They make girls think that the only thing they should do is work on
their appearance, because their opinions don’t matter. This results in several
girls falling into depression or developing eating disorders. The inner
struggles of keeping the pain in cause some girls to want to commit suicide
before wanting to be fat.
Effects of Beauty
Why are standards of beauty being imposed on women, the majority of whom are
naturally larger and more mature than any of the models? The roots, some
analysts say, are economic. By presenting an ideal difficult to achieve and
maintain the cosmetic and diet product industries are assured of growth and
profits. And it’s no accident that youth is increasingly promoted, along with
thinness, as an essential criterion of beauty. If not all women need to lose
weight, for sure they’re all aging, the stakes are huge. On the one hand, women
who are insecure about their bodies are more likely to buy beauty products, new
clothes, and diet aids. . On the other hand, research indicates that exposure to
images of thin, young, air-brushed female bodies is linked to depression, loss
of self-esteem and the development of unhealthy eating habits in women and
girls.
Shaping up Women’s through Thinness Advertisements
Women’s magazines have ten and one-half times more ads promoting weight loss
than men’s magazines do, and over three-quarters of the covers of women’s
magazines include at least one message about how to change a woman’s bodily
appearance—by diet, exercise or cosmetic surgery.
Television and movies reinforce the importance of a thin body as a measure of a
woman’s worth. Pakistani researcher Alam reports that over three-quarters of the
female characters in TV situation comedies are underweight, and only one in
twenty are above average in size. Heavier actresses tend to receive negative
comments from male characters about their bodies ("How about wearing a sack?"),
and 80 per cent of these negative comments are followed by audience laughter.
There have been efforts in the magazine industry to buck the trend. For several
years the Quebec magazine has consistently included full-sized women in their
fashion pages has pledged not to touch up photos and not to include models less
than 25 years of age.
However, advertising rules the marketplace and in advertising thin is "in."
Twenty years ago, the average model weighed 8 per cent less than the average
woman—but today’s models weigh 23 per cent less. Advertisers believe that thin
models sell products. When the Pakistani magazine Fashion recently included a
picture of a heavy-set model on its cover, it received a truckload of letters
from grateful readers praising the move. But its advertisers complained and the
magazine returned to featuring bone-thin models.
Advertising Age International concluded that the incident "made
clear the influence wielded by advertisers who remain convinced that only thin
models spur the sales of beauty products."
Self-Improvement through Advertisement
Messages about thinness, dieting and beauty tell "ordinary" women that they are
always in need of adjustment—and that the female body is an object to be
perfected.
Shaheen argues that the cluttering of media images of painfully thin women means
that real women’s bodies have become invisible in the mass media. The real
tragedy, Shaheen concludes, is that many women internalize these stereotypes,
and judge themselves by the beauty industry's standards. Women learn to compare
themselves to other women, and to compete with them for male attention. Focus on
beauty and desirability "effectively destroys any awareness and action that
might help to change that climate."
Portrayal of Women in Outdoor Advertising
Based upon the findings of a year-long data collection and subsequent data
analysis of outdoor advertising images, this paper provides insight into themes
relating to the portrayals of women on billboards and in other outdoor displays
in Pakistan. While existing research, along with certain high profile
advertising campaigns, may infer that there is a growing trend towards diversity
of portrayals relating to age, ethnicity, body size and activities, my research
indicates that women in contemporary advertising continue to be portrayed as
young, white, thin and idle. Findings of our research and raises issues
regarding the possible negative consequences that ensue for the display of these
homogeneous representations. These consequences include social exclusion and
sexual harassment.
Emergence of Women as Consumers
Traditionally, the role of wife and mother has been seen as a woman’s destiny
and she only career choice. For years, she remained totally dependent on her
husband financially and chose to remain unaware of the world outside her home.
It was the man who was the consumer for the whole family and thus a target for
marketers. However, in the last 10 years, the rapid strides in education and
employment have paved the way for drastic changes in the status of women—the
latter have become self-reliant and also share enhanced emotional bonds with
their husbands. From the woman confined to the domestic sphere to the liberated
woman of the 21st century, from the woman totally dependent on a man to the
totally independent career woman of today, women have made their way through and
have evolved as individuals in their own right. And as far as the notion of
consumers is concerned, women have become the target market for products and
services in Pakistan.
Gender in Advertising
Advertising seems to be obsessed with gender and sexuality and continues to
represent an arena in which gender display plays a major role. It has emerged as
a world of ‘commercial realism’ in which we are given ‘realistic’ images of
domestic life and male-female relationships which are not actually real but
which provide us with a ‘stimulated slice of life’. As gender representation is
such a dominant feature of modern-day advertising, it is often called the social
resource ‘used most’ by advertisers. In turn, advertising provides an ideal
place to examine the encoding of cultural norms and values in ritualized
formats. Increasing popularity of women’s magazines in Pakistan.
Bearing in mind that Pakistan has a very low literacy rate, the trend of
magazines as an informative and entertaining medium has comparatively gained
enormous popularity among the increasing urban population of Pakistan. Magazines
in Pakistan are regarded as a strategic informational, educational and cultural
institution as well as the fifth state of public inquest. They are read for
gaining knowledge, for recreation and for equipping oneself with the latest
information. Women’s magazines were introduced in the Pakistani market only
after the women’s liberation movement. They now reach out to women in both urban
and rural societies in Pakistan and cater to women in terms of their age, class
and role. The market for women’s magazines is increasing at such a rapid pace
that it is no more flooded only with domestic women’s magazines but also with
global ones choose to cater to an elite audience. And the ad agencies that
create the advertisements in these magazines strive to promote a sophisticated
consumerist culture and encourage the readers to imitate the style, philosophy
and format of western magazines and advertisements.
Gender differences in children's reactions to advertisements
The most basic of research has revealed that males and females respond
differently to the images they see in television advertisements, for example,
notes that it is regarded as more effective to target men with advertisements
classed as neutral, because males will not use products even vaguely regarded as
'feminine', while women are more likely to use those products normally classed
as 'male'. Since these attitudinal features are apparent in adulthood, I feel it
is reasonable to presume that such views are likely to be formed, by the viewer,
in childhood. Hence, the issues of gender portrayal in advertising remain at the
centre of the debate.
Smith refers to an interesting study of child-play conducted by Smetana and that
appears to echo Barthel's view of adult purchasing patterns in terms of gendered
products, with males preferring male-specific products in contrast with more
flexible female attitude. Their study revealed that when boys were playing in
all-male groups, they consistently played with male rather than female sex-typed
toys. Girls, in contrast, were seen to play with more female-type toys. The most
interesting findings emerged when the children were observed playing in
mixed-sex groups, since the boys were completely unwilling to play with
female-type toys whereas the girls had no objection to playing with toys that
would generally be regarded as 'male'. Surely advertising companies much take
these attitudes into account when creating their toy advertisements. With these
behavioral differences in mind, Smith proceeds in the study of advertisements to
assess whether such differences may be observed in terms of gender presentation
on the screen.
Advertising in Women’s Magazines
As advertising vehicles, women’s magazines are among the most desirable of
publications and are aimed at the sector of the population traditionally more
responsible for purchases. The strength of these magazines rests principally on
the crucial role of women in the consumption process. The front cover of a
magazine is the vehicle by which the consumer distinguishes one magazine from
another and serves to label not only the magazine but also the consumer who
possesses it. Women’s magazines use their front covers as advertisements for
themselves. Their cover pictures and names, whether it’s Hers, She, Women’s
World or Women’s Era, that these journals are for women only. The cover shapes
the reader’s understanding of the material in the inside pages.
Female Role Portrayals in Women’s Magazines
In recent years widespread attention has been drawn to the roles portrayed by
women in advertisements. In certain cultures, the mainstream media still
reinforces the stereotyped image of a woman whose identity has been shaped by
the limited roles she has to play in society and on screen. The media not only
reflects social values, attitudes and behavior towards women very subtly but
also at times distorts the images of women.
A study in 2000 in Pakistan revealed that magazine advertisements presented the
following clichés about women’s roles:
(1) A woman’s place is in the home,
(2) Women do not make important decisions,
(3) Women are dependent and need men’s protection, and
(4) Men regard women primarily as sexual objects; they’re not interested in
women as people.
Criticism from feminist leaders against this presentation of women in
advertising, the National Advertising Review Board (NARB) established a panel to
address charges that advertising was rampantly sexist in the 1990s. Women were
often portrayed as housewives and too infrequently as professionals. Women were
featured as sex objects to the exclusion of their individuality and portrayed
often as dependent, requiring men to solve their problems. However, since 1998,
advertisers have become increasingly sensitive to the issue of
stereotyping—there is less stereotyping of women as physical objects, and a
trend towards portrayals using either ‘family’ or ‘independent’ cues is visible.
Even though the developing nations have directed increasingly sharp criticism at
the mass media for the so-called stereotyped portrayals of women in traditional
wife and mother roles, women are still not seen as individuals in their own
right. Today in Pakistan, women are entrepreneurs in their own right, but the
press coverage of their efforts is minimal. And even if a woman is projected as
a professional, she is first viewed as somebody’s daughter or wife.
Until very recently, Pakistani magazine advertisements continued to portray
women in their stereotypical images. A woman was either shown in the kitchen
cooking food, washing a bucketful of clothes, bandaging wounds or feeding her
husband and children.
Therefore, the picture that emerged was that of a woman who never produced
knowledge or wealth but always consumed and remained a sort of hanger-on to her
male. In addition to this, advertising was anti-woman, treating her as a sex
symbol. Projection of women in advertisements have shown that whether she was
used for advertising cosmetics, fabrics, jewellery, domestic gadgets, suitcases,
scooters or stationery, a woman was mostly projected as glamorous or enticing.
Another trend in advertisements of men’s clothes was the invariable use of
admiring women by the side of men which created an impression that all a woman
desired was a man dressed in sophisticated garments.
However, in the post-feministic 1990’s and subsequently, advertisers have been
attempting to construct multiple possible identities for women in an effort to
change their stereotypical image and enhance their spending power. In Pakistan,
nowhere is this trend reflected more clearly than in advertising imagery, where
the image of the ‘new Indian woman’ is expressed explicitly. Today in Pakistan,
women appear less frequently dependent upon men while men are less likely to be
depicted in themes of sex appeal, dominance over women and as authority figures.
Advertisements have also started portraying women more frequently as
career-oriented and in non-traditional activities and are constructing the
persona of the ‘new Pakistani woman’.
Bearing in mind the importance of the ‘new Pakistani woman’ as a consumer,
advertisers have targeted this profile in a systematic manner. With the increase
in urban population, the trend is of booming consumerism. Based on extensive
market research, advertisements for goods and services are now addressed to the
growing class of urban middle-class woman with either independent salaries or
who have an increasing control in purchase decisions.
Even with the entry of global products as well as advertising, the role played
by the Pakistani woman in advertising is still very much Pakistani—in the sense
that strategies of advertising representation are careful to avoid a
‘westernized’ image of her. Hence, media producers attempt to construct a
cognate, pan-Indian identity for this ‘new woman’, cutting across regional,
linguistic, caste and other differences. In this way Pakistan, with its own
social and cultural imperatives, has managed to keep its distinctive cultural
baggage even in the face of an increasingly open market system.
Decorative Role Portrayal
Decorative models are passive and non-functional and their primary activity is
to adorn the product/service as a sexual or attractive stimulus. They are like
the least lifelike of roles. ‘She’ is in an artificial world, often obviously so
in the way she stands and looks (dummy poses and catalogue expressions). She is
on exhibition in competition with others. She is aloof, haughty, and ostensibly
sufficient unto herself, while relying on others to reinforce her self-image.
Her outdoor image tends to be exotic and her indoor one non-domestic.
Recreational Role Portrayal
The recreational portrayal is of models in a non-working activity of leisure
(reading, watching television) or of sports (hiking, jogging, swimming, and
boating). The importance of these ads is that women are not shown in passive
poses, a pattern portrayal that every study on gender roles has shown to be
prevalent. In the past, the Indian woman was seen as someone very sensitive and
delicate. Recreational activities mentioned earlier were, therefore, not
connected with women but with men.
Independent Career Role Portrayal
The independent career woman is the only woman involved in something that does
not have to do with social success, home and family, or even her own femininity.
She has stability and a substantial nature. She is portrayed infrequently. Women
in India are rapidly advancing towards becoming financially independent
individuals by seeking higher education and opting for a career rather than
remaining housewives for the rest of their lives.
Self-Involved role portrayal
The self-involved female is the woman who is literally wrapped up in herself.
She is aware of her femininity and sensuality rather than the presence of any
potential lover. She may be portrayed in a ad of romance, perhaps with a man,
and is more bound up with dreams of her own than with the actuality of the man.
The ubiquitous diamond engagement ring advertisements are almost perfect
examples e.g. De Beers. Here, attention is focused on the woman’s feelings about
herself where she has a typically soft expression and directs her attention and
tactility towards herself. She is alone with herself, involved with her body,
thoughts and beauty.
Carefree Role Portrayal
The carefree woman is always a girl or a woman with a girlish look, which gives
one a sense of a short spell of deceptive freedom. She is like a fluttering
butterfly which has not yet decided where to settle. She is having fun while
she’s young. The care freeness or friendliness is social in nature to some
extent and outgoing as well.
Yet, the cheeriness are rarely directed towards anyone or anything in particular
and are only held in the minds of the actor, for example in the girl’s ads. It
must be noted that since the ‘carefree girl’ is very much into herself and
looking for some excitement in her life, she is mostly shown on her own and very
rarely with a man or a child.
Family Role Portrayal
The family or domestic management role is described in ads in which women are
shown performing household wife’s character, taking care of children, or
supervising home furnishing or maintenance. An example would be in the home
environment where the house, its furnishings, its decoration, and the food
served in it are marks of a woman’s sophistication, fashion awareness, sense of
good taste and status. She is proud of this world which is her creation, but
cannot possibly escape from it. A comparative study on gender displays in
Pakistani and Indian advertisements by Kaleem showed that over three times as
many images of women as domestic managers appeared in ads.
The Illustrated Weekly of Pakistan than in Life. MAG & Fashion had about twice
as many domestic management portrayals as Newsweek. More than three times as
many images of body display appeared in Life as The Illustrated Weekly of
Pakistan. Therefore, one can say that Pakistani advertisements do portray women
in their traditional roles till today, although because of the influence of
western society, this trend is changing—more and more advertisements portray
women as career-oriented and persons who are not just expected to remain in the
confines of their homes but are outgoing and enjoy an active social life.
Nudity
There is a related phenomenon that may possess even more long-term significance
both for marketing managers and society in general. This trend is towards
increasing nudity in advertisements. Nudity, even if not on large scale as
currently portrayed, has been common in women’s advertisements for some years.
Feature of advertisements for products of the feminine sort and is private,
isolated and a source of wonder, pleasure, and satisfaction to the subject.
Moreover, the body is considered to be an object to admire or even revere in a
quasi-religious way.
The use of sexual appeal is hardly new. What is new is the intensity of such
appeal and the increasing number and variety of products being marketed with
sexual overtones. Now not only are nude models used to advertise well-known
consumer products such as cosmetics, skin equipment, and wearing apparel, but
they are also used by industrial companies. No longer is nudity employed solely
as a shock device. It is increasingly being used in a more sophisticated sense
in a functional communication role.
Sexuality has been linked directly with advertisements because it is usual for
young women to compare themselves to models in advertisements — thus,
advertisers feel they can be persuaded to buy the product. For women, and to a
lesser extent for men, the ‘sexual revolution’ has meant a positive increase in
the amount of their sexual freedom. It has also meant an increase in their ‘use’
as sexual objects. The use of dramatic, isolating shadows, mysterious darkness
and focus are common techniques of transporting the female into a personal world
of self-contemplation.
Urban Pakistan is slowly transforming into a western society. The West, through
the various media, is increasingly influencing this sector of the Pakistani
economy, especially in terms of its fashion—and nowhere is this trend more
prominent than in Pakistani women’s fashion magazines. This shows that even
though Pakistan advertisements have Pakistani models with traditional dresses,
they are being increasingly replaced with models in western outfits or have
other western aspects to them. It is only in the last 20 years that Pakistan has
opened up to western culture. With the advent of privatization and the
liberalisation of the economy, Pakistan has seen a surge of multinationals
attract their consumer market. And the new revolution in advertising is also a
true revelation of the changed consumer scenario.
The presence of an increasing number of women’s magazines, as well as
advertising in these magazines portraying the different roles of women, clearly
reveal the changing perception of women in today’s society. As marketers, unlike
before, are investing large sums of money and time, investigating and collecting
data solely on women’s psychographics—attitudes, habits, preferences—to meet
their needs and wants, it is obvious that women today are no longer remain in
their traditions but have transfer western culture to their convenience. This
change of traditional culture with western culture not only reflects the
metamorphosis of women in society but also reveals the new Pakistani market—a
revolutionized consumer marketplace
EFFECTS OF STEREOTYPES
The repetition of these images may have serious consequences. Naturally,
if people come to accept these images as true, then misrepresentation occurs.
These stereotypes seem to give us permission to overlook the individuality of
people and the particulars of any situation. They can hatred and fear of
specific groups of people. They can affect one's own perceptions of his
race or sex. They can place impossible demands, such as the beauty
stereotypes of women in advertising, on individuals and foster a lack of
self-esteem. Stereotypes influence our perceptions of ourselves and
others. Stereotypes, repeated often enough, come to be viewed as
reality rather than a chosen representation.
Resisting Stereotypes and Working for Change
Many media activists argue that producers should be called to account, and that
images of women should be forced to be more realistic.
Some producers have taken the lead. In the late 1990s, Kellogg released an ad
campaign for Special K which used pictures of older and larger women, and copy
such as "the Ashantis of Ghana think a woman's body gets more attractive as she
ages. Please contact your travel agent for the next available flight." The ads
attracted such positive attention that in 1999 they were followed up by a TV
campaign.
Self-Image, & Stereotypes
Silently reading an article about the images of women in advertising, one of my
11th-grade female students looked up and snarled: "This media literacy stuff is
making me mad.
What it meant to have her illusions of something shattered.
Many of advertisements and consumers of media. They purchase t-shirts, hats, and
backpacks embossed with the ubiquitous Nike swoosh symbol. They sport images of
their favorite heavy-metal band and sports team. Typically, they will have
accumulated 22,000 hours of television viewing by the time they graduate from
high school, which is twice the amount of time they will have spent in school.
They will have seen 350,000 television commercials by the age of 17.
We may not admit it, but our students are often more influenced by the popular
media outside our classrooms than they are by the novels and textbooks we often
must bribe them to read. Thus, media literacy can play a necessary role in
helping our students become critically literate and reactive to the powerful
influence of television, video games, commercial advertising, popular magazines,
and movies.
IMAGES OF WOMEN
How images and ads shape our values. Ads, not only sell products, but sell ideas
about romance, sex, success, beauty, and power. Ads, she says, "will have you
believe that women in the real world are all white and under 40; that no one is
disabled and everyone is heterosexual; that a woman's body is in constant need
of improvement; that women need to look young, 'beautiful,' made-up, sprayed up,
very thin, and perfectly groomed."
Sadly, these images are part of a culture in which one out of five women has a
serious eating disorder such as anorexia; where adolescent girls increasingly
have problems with low self-esteem; and where Blacks, especially women, have
historically had serious problems and prejudices concerning the lightness and
darkness of their skin.
Especially the young women, presented the magazine ads, they talked of how no
one they knew could possibly acquire the physical appearance of the models. And
they began to articulate how women, and even men, are sexualized in the ads in
order to sell products.
Sex and Relationships in the Media
The pressure put on women through ads, television, film and new media to be
sexually attractive—and sexually active—is profound. The National Eating
Disorders Association reports that one out of four TV commercials send some kind
of "attractiveness message," telling viewers what is and is not attractive.
Children Now reports that 38 per cent of the female characters in video games
are scantily clad, 23 per cent baring breasts or cleavage, 31 per cent exposing
thighs, another 31 per cent exposing stomachs or midriffs, and 15 per cent
baring their behinds.
Women as Sexual Objects
Provocative images of women's partly clothed or naked bodies are especially
prevalent in advertising. Women become sexual objects when their bodies and
their sexuality are linked to products that are bought and sold.
She notes that women’s bodies are often dismembered into legs, breasts or
thighs, reinforcing the message that women are objects rather than whole human
beings.
Although women’s sexuality is no longer a subject, many researchers question
whether or not the blatant sexualization of women’s bodies in the media is
liberating. Those "lies" continue to perpetuate the idea that women’s sexuality
is subservient to men’s pleasure, for example, found that both men and women’s
magazines contain a single vision of female sexuality—that "women should
primarily concern themselves with attracting and sexually satisfying men."
The presence of misinformation and media stereotypes is disturbing, given
research that indicates young people often turn to media for information about
sex and sexuality. In 2003, Sara reported that two-thirds of young people turn
to media when they want to learn about sex - the same percentage of kids who ask
their mothers for information and advice.
How to Catch (and Keep) you’re Man
Many researchers argue that the over-representation of thin women in mass media
reinforces the conclusion that "physically attractive" and "sexually desirable"
mean "thin." The fascination with finding out what men really want also tends to
keep female characters in film and television busy. Female characters, on the
other hand, are more likely to be seen dating, or talking about romance.
Stereotype Threat
Besides acknowledging the fact that television media often offers negative
stereotypical portrayals of individuals belonging to certain racial and/or
ethnic groups such as African-Americans and homosexuals, social psychology goes
further by examining the direct implications of these mostly negative images.
One of these implications is the notion of
stereotype threat, the risk of confirming
a negative stereotype about one’s group as self characteristic. As an
individual is constantly exposed to negative images of his/her racial or ethnic
group, this person begins to internalize the same social and personal
characteristics of these images.
Numerous psychological effects of stereotype threat in areas such as
standardized tests, and athletic performance. For example, the commonly
held assumption that women are less skilled in mathematics than men has been
shown to affect the performance of women on standardized math tests. When
female participants were primed beforehand of this negative stereotype, scores
were significantly lower than
if the women were led to believe the tests did not reflect these stereotypes.
Going hand in hand with the idea of stereotype threat, the negative television
portrayals have a direct correlation with the effects of the self-fulfilling.
Although not in the realm of primetime television, channels such as MTV offer
blatantly stereotypical images of African-Americans and women that greatly
affect the young viewers who, in turn take these images to heart. Videos
lead young black males to internalize a positive image of Black culture that
emphasizes the degradation of women as objects, the lurid appeal of money, and
material possessions, as well as the endorsement of alcohol and drug use.
With constant exposure to these images, it is no surprise that we have seen many
instances of young black men attempting to emulate these images through overt
behaviors such as drug use, domestic violence, and criminal activity.
In terms of primetime television, an issue that has been in the news recently is
how many women are seen on television represented by unrealistically thin images
of many prominent actresses in Hollywood. While television images provide
only one aspect of our culture that leads women to desire these traits, it
deserves the most attention because of how pervasive television has become in
American society. The negative impact of these media trends is seen in the
many women who suffer from eating disorders such as anorexia and bulimia in
hopes of reaching a slim figure.
Stereotype-Breaking Actions
Stereotype breaking actions are actions that one party can take to prove to
their opponents that they are better in character than the opponent assumes. For
example, one party may visit the opponent personally, and be more reasonable,
friendlier, more agreeable, or more helpful than the opponent expected. When
this happens, they are likely to revise their enemy image at least a little bit,
concluding that some members of the opposition are reasonable people, or even
that the opponents, in general, are more reasonable than they thought they were.
This effectively broke down many people's stereotypes of Pakistani’s as hostile,
cold, and aggressive, and replaced those images with an image much more friendly
and open.
In addition to making trips to the opposing country or group, other stereotype
breaking actions are possible as well. One must simply determine what the other
side thinks of you or expects of you, and then do the opposite. If you are
expected to be closed to new ideas, express and interest in listening to new
approaches to the problem. If you are expected to be selfish and aggressive,
take a nonassertive stance and make a small concession that demonstrates good
will and a willingness to cooperate with the other side. The goal is simply to
contradict the negative images that people usually have of their opponents, and
begin to replace these negative images with more positive ones
Negative Effects of Gender-Role Stereotyping on Males & Females
Negative Effects on Females
Academic
-
Less assertive in the classroom; males call out the answers and
get the teacher's attention, while females sit patiently with
their hands raised.
-
Face more reprimands from teachers for calling out answers than
males.
-
Teachers more likely to do things for female students, which
reinforces dependence; males more likely to get detailed
instructions for doing things themselves.
-
Females less likely to take math and science courses or
participate in special or gifted programs in these areas.
-
Females participate less actively in discussions; they do more
smiling and gazing and are more often passive bystanders in
conversations.
-
Whereas males receive feedback for their task performance,
females receive feedback related to their appearance
-
Whereas males receive messages that they can succeed if they
exert effort, females receive messages that less is expected and
accepted: "you can do it if you try," versus "well, at least you
tried".
-
As teachers solve problems for female students and do not
encourage them to work through a problem, females can develop
"learned helplessness".
-
Females more likely to attribute success to external causes and
failure to internal causes; failure seen as insurmountable;
"It's just me, I'm not good at this and I can never succeed"
versus "If I put in more effort I can succeed".
-
Teachers interact with males and females differently, more often
attributing the failure of boys to lack of effort rather than to
lack of ability.
-
Female students receive less encouragement to achieve in the
classroom.
-
The classroom actually spends more time on male learning
deficits than on the learning deficits of females; female
students are not the primary focus of the energy and resources
of the school.
-
Female students get less special intervention on their behalf in
the classroom.
-
Even though females start out ahead of males in early grades,
achievement test scores of females fall as they reach high
school.
Ethical issue of Political Marketing
Political advertising can support and assist the working of the democratic
process, but it also can obstruct it. This happens when, for example, the costs
of advertising limit political competition to wealthy candidates or groups, or
require that office-seekers compromise their integrity and independence by
over-dependence on special interests for funds. Such obstruction of the
democratic process also happens when, instead of being a vehicle for honest
expositions of candidates' views and records, political advertising seeks to
distort the views and records of opponents and unjustly attacks their
reputations. It happens when advertising appeals more to people's emotions and
base instincts-to selfishness, bias and hostility toward others, to racial and
ethnic prejudice and the like- rather than to a reasoned sense of justice and
the good of all
HARM DONE BY ADVERTISING
There is nothing intrinsically good or intrinsically evil about advertising. It
is a tool, an instrument: it can be used well, and it can be used badly. If it
can have, and sometimes does have, beneficial results such as those just
described, it also can, and often does, have a negative, harmful impact on
individuals and society.
Communio Progressio
contains this summary statement of the problem: "If harmful or utterly useless
goods are touted to the public, if false assertions are made about goods for
sale, if less than admirable human tendencies are exploited, those responsible
for such advertising harm society and forfeit their good name and credibility.
More than this, unremitting pressure to buy articles of luxury can arouse false
wants that hurt both individuals and families by making them ignore what they
really need. And those forms of advertising which, without shame, exploit the
sexual instincts simply to make money or which seek to penetrate into the
subconscious recesses of the mind in a way that threatens the freedom of the
individual ... must be shunned."
a) Economic Harms of Advertising
Advertising can betray its role as a source of information by misrepresentation
and by withholding relevant facts. Sometimes, too, the information function of
media can be subverted by advertisers' pressure upon publications or programs
not to treat of questions that might prove embarrassing or inconvenient.
More often, though, advertising is used not simply to inform but to persuade and
motivate — to convince people to act in certain ways: buy certain products or
services, patronize certain institutions, and the like. This is where particular
abuses can occur.
The practice of "brand"-related advertising can raise serious problems. Often
there are only negligible differences among similar products of different
brands, and advertising may attempt to move people to act on the basis of
irrational motives ("brand loyalty," status, fashion, "sex appeal," etc.)
instead of presenting differences in product quality and price as bases for
rational choice.
Advertising also can be, and often is, a tool of the "phenomenon of
consumerism," as Pope John Paul II delineated it when he said: "It is not wrong
to want to live better; what is wrong is a style of life which is presumed to be
better when it is directed toward? having’ rather than ?being', and which wants
to have more, not in order to be more but in order to spend life in enjoyment as
an end in itself."
Sometimes advertisers speak of it as part of their task to "create" needs for
products and services — that is, to cause people to feel and act upon cravings
for items and services they do not need. "If ... a direct appeal is made to his
instincts — while ignoring in various ways the reality of the person as
intelligent and free — then consumer attitudes and life-styles can be created
which are objectively improper and often damaging to his physical and spiritual
health."
This is a serious abuse, an affront to human dignity and the common good when it
occurs in affluent societies. But the abuse is still more grave when consumerist
attitudes and values are transmitted by communications media and advertising to
developing countries, where they exacerbate socio-economic problems and harm the
poor. "It is true that a judicious use of advertising can stimulate developing
countries to improve their standard of living.
But serious harm can be done them if advertising and commercial pressure become
so irresponsible that communities seeking to rise from poverty to a reasonable
standard of living are persuaded to seek this progress by satisfying wants that
have been artificially created. The result of this is that they waste their
resources and neglect their real needs, and genuine development falls behind."
Similarly, the task of countries attempting to develop types of market economies
that serve human needs and interests after decades under centralized,
state-controlled systems is made more difficult by advertising that promotes
consumerist attitudes and values offensive to human dignity and the common good.
The problem is particularly acute when, as often happens, the dignity and
welfare of society's poorer and weaker members are at stake. It is necessary
always to bear in mind that there are "goods which by their very nature cannot
and must not be bought or sold" and to avoid "an? Idolatry’ of the market" that
aided and abetted by advertising, ignores this crucial fact.
b) Harms of Political Advertising
Political advertising can support and assist the working of the democratic
process, but it also can obstruct it. This happens when, for example, the costs
of advertising limit political competition to wealthy candidates or groups, or
require that office-seekers compromise their integrity and independence by
over-dependence on special interests for funds.
Such obstruction of the democratic process also happens when, instead of being a
vehicle for honest expositions of candidates' views and records, political
advertising seeks to distort the views and records of opponents and unjustly
attacks their reputations. It happens when advertising appeals more to people's
emotions and base instincts — to selfishness, bias and hostility toward others,
to racial and ethnic prejudice and the like — rather than to a reasoned sense of
justice and the good of all.
c) Cultural Harms of Advertising
Advertising also can have a corrupting influence upon culture and cultural
values. We have spoken of the economic harm that can be done to developing
nations by advertising that fosters consumerism and destructive patterns of
consumption.
Consider also the cultural injury done to these nations and their peoples by
advertising whose content and methods, reflecting those prevalent in the first
world, are at war with sound traditional values in indigenous cultures. Today
this kind of "domination and manipulation" via media rightly is "a concern of
developing nations in relation to developed ones," as well as a "concern of
minorities within particular nations."
The indirect but powerful influence exerted by advertising upon the media of
social communications that depend on revenues from this source points to another
sort of cultural concern. In the competition to attract ever larger audiences
and deliver them to advertisers, communicators can find themselves tempted — in
fact pressured, subtly or not so subtly — to set aside high artistic and moral
standards and lapse into superficiality, tawdriness and moral squalor.
Communicators also can find themselves tempted to ignore the educational and
social needs of certain segments of the audience — the very young, the very old,
the poor — who do not match the demographic patterns (age, education, income,
habits of buying and consuming, etc.) of the kinds of audiences advertisers want
to reach. In this way the tone and indeed the level of moral responsibility of
the communications media in general are lowered.
All too often, advertising contributes to the invidious stereotyping of
particular groups that places them at a disadvantage in relation to others. This
often is true of the way advertising treats women; and the exploitation of
women, both in and by advertising, is a frequent, deplorable abuse.
"How often are they treated not as persons with an inviolable dignity but as
objects whose purpose is to satisfy others' appetite for pleasure or for power?
How often the role of woman as wife and mother is undervalued or even ridiculed?
How often is the role of women in business or professional life depicted as a
masculine caricature, a denial of the specific gifts of feminine insight,
compassion, and understanding, which so greatly contribute to the ?civilization
of love'? Many studies suggest media can have negative effects...
·
Violence on TV fueling aggression
·
Stereotyping of minorities
·
Information anxiety
·
Media-induced passivity
·
Well-informed futility
Prejudice and stereotyping are apparent everywhere in today's society. People
are stereotyped and discriminated against whether it is when trying to find a
job or being picked for a sports team. Most of the time there is no reason for
this prejudice. However, there is more prejudice in sports than most activities.
Throughout my life I have seen a lot of stereotyping and prejudice in sports.
When my friends and I had to pick teams for basketball games everyone was
immediately stereotyped. No one ever wanted to be a captain because they would
have to choose teams. If you were tall or played for the varsity team you were
always picked right away. On the other hand, if you were short or not very
athletic you were either picked last or not picked at all. I was fortunate, for
me things were never that bad. Since I was tall and played on our high school's
team I was usually one of the first picked. As for the kids who were less
fortunate it must have been an embarrassment to be picked last or not picked at
all. The looks on their faces explained exactly how they felt. They always
looked hurt and disappointed; this made me understand exactly how bad it feels
to be stereotyped.
Why is there so much stereotyping in sports?
In sports today there is something called gender logic. Gender logic usually
works to the advantage of men, and to the disadvantage of women. In sport in
America there are many different perspectives and ideas about gender, about
masculinity and femininity. That is why when people play sports today after all
the cultural brain washing they come to the conclusion that women were naturally
inferior to men in any activity requiring strength, physical skills, and
emotional control. We all now that this is not necessarily true because there
are many sports that woman can compete equally with men in.
What has basically come out of all this gender stereotyping in sports is that if
someone does not throw a ball well it is said that they throw like a girl for
example. That goes for every other sport because if something is done right your
doing in like a man and if something goes wrong everyone is doing the activity
like a bunch of girls. Today we are ever so slowly falling out of this gender
stereotyping in sports.
Another place where stereotyping and prejudice come into play is in the work
force. It is sad that a deciding factor in getting a job has to do with your
looks, race, and gender. I remember one of my close friends telling me a story
about how he was discriminated against when looking for a job. My friend, who is
of a white background, saw a now hiring sign outside of Mini Mart and decided to
go in and apply for a job. When he walked in he asked for an application, the
manager of the story who was of an Indian background told him there was no more
position available, so my friend left. Only a few days later another friend of
mine who is of an Indian background went into the store to apply for the job.
The manager of the store told him that he did not need to fill out an
application and that they would hire him on the spot. I was very disappointed
when I found this out. I feel that it is ridiculous that a kid who has been a
customer in that store many times was denied a job imply because of his race. In
conclusion, stereotyping and discrimination have become a part of everyday life.
People are discriminated against because of their physical attributes, their
race, and their gender.
d) Moral and Religious Harms of Advertising
Advertising can be tasteful and in conformity with high moral standards, and
occasionally even morally uplifting, but it also can be vulgar and morally
degrading. Frequently it deliberately appeals to such motives as envy, status
seeking and lust. Today, too, some advertisers consciously seek to shock and
titillate by exploiting content of a morbid, perverse, pornographic nature.
What this Pontifical Council said several years ago about pornography and
violence in the media is no less true of certain forms of advertising:
"As reflections of the dark side of human nature marred by sin, pornography and
the exaltation of violence are age-old realities of the human condition. In the
past quarter century, however, they have taken on new dimensions and have become
serious social problems. At a time of widespread and unfortunate confusion about
moral norms, the communications media have made pornography and violence
accessible to a vastly expanded audience, including young people and even
children, and a problem which at one time was confined mainly to wealthy
countries has now begun, via the communications media, to corrupt moral values
in developing nations."
We note, too, certain special problems relating to advertising that treats of
religion or pertains to specific issues with a moral dimension.
In cases of the first sort, commercial advertisers sometimes include religious
themes or use religious images or personages to sell products. It is possible to
do this in tasteful, acceptable ways, but the practice is obnoxious and
offensive when it involves exploiting religion or treating it flippantly.
In cases of the second sort, advertising sometimes is used to promote products
and inculcate attitudes and forms of behavior contrary to moral norms. That is
the case, for instance, with the advertising of contraceptives, abortifacients
and products harmful to health, and with government-sponsored advertising
campaigns for artificial birth control, so-called "safe sex", and similar
practices.
Deceptive advertising
Advertising intended to mislead consumers by making claims that are false or
failing to make full disclosure of important facts or both. The current FTC
policy on deception contains three basic elements:
·
Misleading:
Where there is representation, omission, or practice, there must be a high
probability that it will mislead the consumer.
·
Reasonableness:
The perspective of the reasonable consumer is used to judge deception. The FTC
tests reasonableness by looking at whether the consumer’s interpretation or
reaction to an advertisement is reasonable.
Injurious: The deception must lead to material injury. In other words,
the deception must influence consumer’s decision making about products and
services
Poor Taste and Offensive Advertising
Although certain ads might be in bad taste in any circumstance, viewer reactions
are affected by factors such as sensitivity to the product category, the time
the message is received, and whether the person is alone or with others when
viewing the message.
We all have our own ideas about what constitutes good taste. Unfortunately,
these ideas vary so much that creating general guidelines for good taste in
advertising is difficult.
Puffery
Sales representations, which praise the item to be sold with subjective
opinions, superlatives, or exaggerations, vaguely and generally, stating no
specific facts Puffery, an exaggerated claim, is not seen as misleading.
Because exaggerated claims are legal, the question of puffery is mainly an
ethical one. However, empirical evidence on the effectiveness of puffery is
mixed.
Set of laws that governs sales and other commercial matters, distinguishes
between mere Puffing and statements about a products performance or qualities
that create an Express warranty’s Under the UCC, a general statement praising
the value of a product does not create an express warranty. More concrete
representations might.
Unhealthy or Dangerous Products
One way to for an advertiser to make ethical decisions is to choose the route
that does no one harm. Marketers are now being forced to consider the social, as
well as nutritional, impact of their products. It used to be that consumers were
considered responsible for the products they chose to buy, but in a new era of
social responsibility, principled marketers are now more responsible for the
negative effects of the products they choose to sell. Responsibility has become
a new business principle in some industries that never thought they were the
focus of ethical questions.
Tobacco
One of the most heated advertising issues in recent years has been proposed new
restrictions on the advertising of tobacco. Proponents of the ban on cigarette
advertising argue that because cigarettes have been shown to cause cancer as
well as other illnesses, encouraging tobacco use promotes sickness, injury, or
death for the smoker and those inhaling second-hand smoke. The restriction of
advertising on those products would result in fewer sales and fewer health
problems for America as a whole.
In recognition of the growing public concerns about cigarette marketing,
tobacco companies have voluntarily curbed their advertising and pulled ads from
magazines with high levels of youth readership and from most outdoor billboards.
Opponents of advertising bans counter with the argument that prohibiting
truthful, no deceptive advertising for a legal product is unconstitutional and
cite statistics demonstrating that similar bans in other countries have proved
unsuccessful in reducing tobacco sales.
Ethical Issues in Advertising
Context of Developing Countries
Marketing, in contemporary times, has seen a tumultuous change in the way it’s
conducted in developing countries. The oft cited dictum that only change is
constant in the marketing genre is an apposite one. Just as the media of social
communication themselves have enormous influence everywhere, so advertising and
marketing, using media as their vehicles, are pervasive, powerful forces shaping
attitudes and behavior in today's world.
Four reasons are attributed to the fugacious nature of the way marketing
practices are being carried out in developing countries.
The role of Information and Communication technologies:
As ICTs evolve so do marketing practices. If yesterday it was television
that revolutionized the way advertisements could create a lasting impact on the
consumer, then today the internet and phone text messages are doing just that.
The world today is an increasingly global village: Social and ethnic boundaries
are fast falling in the wake of cable television and the like.
Rapid economic expansions in countries like China and India have meant that
marketers have to quickly respond to the changing socio-economic scenarios.
Millions of people have entered the middle class and millions more are poised to
do so. For marketers, the consequences can be mind boggling-as incomes and
spending powers rise, marketers have to respond to increasing demands from
consumers.
Better and improved marketing research has meant that the entire populace is not
seen in totality but rather as a
congeries of different types of consumers.
The Upshot
But the outcome of such developments is that a number of ethical issues have
arisen. While the globe is indeed becoming a smaller place, marketers have to
bear in mind national, local and cultural sensitivities. Very often, in the hope
of tapping a larger consumer base, marketers jump headlong in new markets
without keeping in mind ethnic and social issues typical to certain areas.
While marketers do have to act with celerity in gaining footholds in emerging
markets such as China and India, care has to be taken in ensuring that the
mores,
etiquettes of the land are not encroached upon. The incorporation
of newer technologies has meant that a number of issues such as invasion of
privacy and credibility have arisen. Engro, in these rapidly changing
circumstances, marketers and consumers alike face a nimiety of ethical issues
that have to be addressed. This paper looks at some of the ethical issues in the
developing countries context.
Exploiting Social Paradigms
In the hopes of making a fast buck, marketers often resort to exploiting social
paradigms typical to certain areas. In India, for example, a large multinational
corporation ran an ad campaign that depicted a young woman who because of her
dark facial complexion was unable to find jobs. But as the ad showed, as soon as
the woman started using the facial whiteness cream manufactured by the
corporation, she got the job of her choice. Needless to say, there was a big
backlash against it and the ad campaign had to be scrapped.
On an ethical standpoint, marketers have to exercise restraint in exploiting
such social paradigms to their commercial advantage.
Surrogate Advertisements
In India alcohol and cigarette advertisements were banned outright some years
back. However, alcohol and cigarette companies alike are using the avenue of
surrogate advertisements to press forward their case. For the viewer though, the
‘subtle’ pointer towards the real deal is enough as the surrogate advertisements
leave no ambiguity in their minds.
Subliminal Advertisements
One of the most controversial and ethical issues in advertising is regarding
subliminal advertisements. Inserting subliminal messages in an advertisement is
an inherently misleading action. It is an attempt to manipulate a person’s
thinking without the person realizing that any such manipulation is occurring.
The west has had its fair share of subliminal advertisements related hullabaloos
primarily because the advertisement, marketing and regulating media themselves
have been quite active in raising such issues.
During the US Presidential elections of 2000, it came to light that a political
advertisement for George W. Bush subliminally flashed the word ‘RATS’ when
criticizing Al Gore’s prescription medicine plan. While the ad maker denied that
the quickly flashed word was a subliminal message designed to surreptitiously
sling mud at Gore, many others, however, concluded that ‘RATS’ was indeed
inserted with the intention of secretly causing viewers’ to associate vermin
with Al Gore. In line with the techniques of subliminal messaging, the
questionable word appeared on the screen for only a microsecond (1/30th of a
second), passing by so fast that it was almost unrecognizable to the conscious
mind-especially when passively lulled by television. According to the theory of
subliminal advertising the image would, indeed, register in a viewer’s
subconscious mind, thereby causing the viewer to negatively associate Al Gore
with a rodent.
The effects of subliminal advertisements are real and financially significant.
Each year, consumers spend roughly Rs50 million for self-help tapes embedded
with subliminal messages that are supposed to teach a person a foreign language
while they sleep, or help them lose weight, or quit smoking. Additionally, some
stores embed subliminal messages in their background music in an effort to
discourage shoplifting. Time magazine reported in 1979 that messages such as ‘I
am an honest person’ and ‘Stealing is dishonest’ were being utilized in over
fifty department stores. One department store utilizing the hidden messages
reported a savings of $US600, 000 by reducing theft 37 percent during a nine
month period.
So, if subliminal messages evidently work in self-help tapes and embedded in
department store music, it certainly seams reasonable that they would also work
and perhaps even work better in a visual medium such as television.
In developing countries the regulating watchdogs and related establishments are
still in stages of latency so that the possibility that viewers who would be
subject to such measures would probably never ever know that they were the focus
of such procedures.
Ethical Issue of ‘Creating Demand’
In the words of Pope John,
advertising also can be, and often is, a tool of the phenomenon of consumerism.
Sometimes advertisers speak of it as part of their task to ‘create’ needs for
products and services - that is, to cause people to feel and act upon desires
for items and services they would ordinarily not need.
A piquant issue arises when consumerist attitudes and values are transmitted by
communications media and advertising to developing countries, where they
exacerbate socio-economic problems and harm the poor. While a judicious use of
advertising can stimulate developing countries to improve their standard of
living, serious harm can be done to them if advertising and commercial pressure
become so irresponsible that communities seeking to rise from poverty to a
reasonable standard of living are persuaded to seek this progress by satisfying
wants that have been artificially created.
The result of this is that they waste their resources and neglect their real
needs, and genuine development falls behind.
False and Misleading Advertisements
Then there is the issue of false and downright disingenuous advertisements.
While in itself this is an important ethical issue, an extension of this is the
question of credibility.
Nowadays, newspaper columns are rife with advertisements which blatantly compare
features of brands with those of their competitors. Citing the opinion of
‘experts’, these advertisements claim their brands to be quantitatively and
qualitatively better than those of their rivals. In India a leading car
manufacturer had to recall its ad campaign when it incorrectly stated that one
of its car models was superior to that of its competitor’s.
Depicting groups in Stereotyped Roles
All too often, marketing contributes to the invidious stereotyping of particular
groups that places them at a disadvantage in relation to others.
Women and children unfortunately end up being cast as stereotypes in ad
campaigns the world over.
Often, the role of women in business or professional life is depicted as a
masculine caricature, a denial of the specific gifts of feminine insight,
compassion, and understanding.
In India, which has traditionally been a patriarchal society, tremendous
cultural changes have been brought in with the advent of cable television and
the exposure to western content. Urban women are enjoying more freedom than
they’ve had before. Yet, promotional campaigns of certain firms still show the
Indian woman of yore-a fallback to a time when women did not enjoy the freedoms
they have today.
Ethical issue of Political Advertising
Political advertising can support and assist the working of the democratic
process, but it also can obstruct it. This happens when, for example, the costs
of advertising limit political competition to wealthy candidates or groups, or
require that office-seekers compromise their integrity and independence by
over-dependence on special interests for funds. Such obstruction of the
democratic process also happens when, instead of being a vehicle for honest
expositions of candidates' views and records, political advertising seeks to
distort the views and records of opponents and unjustly attacks their
reputations. It happens when advertising appeals more to people's emotions and
base instincts-to selfishness, bias and hostility toward others, to racial and
ethnic prejudice and the like- rather than to a reasoned sense of justice and
the good of all.
Advertising is everything with a name on it
The first interesting finding was the extent to which the term advertising
encompassed for consumers every piece of brand, product or service
communication. It obviously included the key media of television, posters
(surprisingly high in a strong second place), press, cinema and radio. It also
included other aspects of ‘selling’ such as Direct Mail, door drops, the
Internet, branding in store, branded clothing, sponsorship, commercial text
messages and even telephone sales. Advertising is simply everything that has a
name on it.
Positive impacts of advertising
Woman sitting at home is not a problem if its the choice SHE makes and it is not
forced down her throat. Ddon’t
you think this applies to men too? Let me ask you a question now. Honestly would
you marry a person who would like to sit at home? Would you give a man that
choice? Why is this choice given only to women then?
Again i am not contesting that women should not stay at home, but what i am
stating is that many a times we are so immersed into thinking about “freedom for
women” that we forget that we are rubbing the basic tenets of nature. Women are
the only ones who can give life and nurture it, men will never be able to do
that, but in our hurry to prove that men and women are equal we often tend to
forget a lot of things nature gave us inherently. I will not explain this point
further because I know it isn’t going to be taken well, but I can only say that
men and women are different, they were made to be that way. Both have common
qualities, and both have specific qualities, that are what makes them different.
The sooner we understand this, the faster we’ll be able to appreciate a lot of
things about men and women.
For decades women have been portrayed as housewives, dependent on men & sex
objects in advertisements. However from past one decade, representation of women
in advertisements has been experiencing a shift from the house wife centric ads
to the career women ads.
Women are also portrayed in ads as unthinking beings preoccupied with trivial
matters. The ads for “Ansal Plaza” & “Grooms In” as shown above, portray them as
shallow, and have mundane thoughts such as shopping and good clothes. The tag
line in print ad 3 (above) illustrates“ Her husband has an extramarital affair
and she knows it”, so as to say that she is not worried or bothered about her
marriage as much as she is about her shopping in the mall. In print ad, two
brides are ‘willing’ to marry the groom, for he is wearing the salwar suits
manufactured by their brand.
The typical portrayal of the housewife, as dependent on her husband is still
prevalent in ads. The “ICICI” Insurance a urges a man “to give his shoulders the
satisfaction of protecting” his wife. The wife in the ad is shown resting her
head on her husbands shoulder so as to represent her dependence on him. The
woman is shown as someone rather “incapable of looking after herself and
requires a husband to do so”
Findings
Public’s view of what advertising is and its role in society
In order to understand how the public views advertising and the role it plays in
their lives it is important to explore exactly what is included by consumers in
the term advertising.
Advertising is everything that has a name on it
Not surprisingly the obvious media immediately emerge as part of advertising.
Television, Billboards (the term most commonly used), Magazines and Newspapers
are all mentioned very quickly. Radio and Cinema are also included but require a
little more probing. Not all respondents listen to commercial radio or go to the
cinema and so are less likely to have these media top of mind. Transport
advertising, usually referred to as tube or bus advertising, is as readily
mentioned as radio or cinema particularly in the South where the dominance of
the London transport network is apparent.
What is perhaps more surprising is how quickly respondents included the other
‘below the line’ media in their concept of advertising. So there was very
frequent mention of Direct Mail, door drops, sponsorship, the Internet,
commercial text messages and advertising in supermarkets. Advertising was also
seen to include telephone sales, heavily product branded magazine features,
brand names on fashion items, brand mentions in distribution outlets and branded
carrier bags. In other words advertising is ‘anything that has a name on it’.
“It’s just in everything, newspapers and magazines and it’s on television, you
know you go in the high street and it’s in the shop windows…it’s on everything
you do without realizing it” Female
Advertising is all -embracing
The all embracing concept of advertising was a widely held one although the
older respondents (anyone over the age of 25) felt this was very much a new
phenomenon, whereas the younger respondents felt they had grown up with
advertising being all pervasive.
The all-embracing nature of advertising means that all respondents believe it is
absolutely part of everyday life. As such it is as much part of the environment
as the traffic and the trees. It is simply everywhere.
“It’s all round advertising, you are completely blitzed by advertising, it
doesn’t matter what you do, you tend to find a big advert” Male 20-24
|